{"built":"2026-10-31T22:44:33.057Z","clade":"Aves","label":"birds","provisional":false,"decision":{"clade":"Aves","status":"confirmed","decided_by":"Amit Shenoy, project lead, in his own words to the hub: \"Sure do AVes\"","relayed_by":"hub session scienceclaw-03 to the holdout thread (scienceclaw-93)","decided_on":"2026-10-31","provisional_from":"2026-10-31T05:52:44.982Z","alternative_considered":"Mammalia","reasoning":["Aves was chosen knowing it is underpowered for the tests built so far: the held-out bird counts fall below the builders’ own pre-registered minimum sample sizes, so both examined tests read inconclusive.","Mammalia would have made 1 of 2 examined tests decisive, but the examined tests had already fitted on mammal rows, and one further completed test uses mammals only and would have been built entirely on held-out data; a switch now would have made those tests post hoc.","The choice was therefore a clean blind that cannot yet decide over a decisive-looking test on a contaminated design, and the clean blind was taken.","The finding this records is about the data, not the thread: the public trait and demographic tables cannot support a blind clade exam at the builders’ own minimum n for these laws. That is more useful to the next team than a decisive number from a compromised design."],"cost":{"examined_tests":["kimura-heterozygosity","hamilton-senescence"],"held_out_counts":[{"test":"kimura-heterozygosity","clade":"Aves","held_out_n":13,"builder_min_n":50,"verdict":"inconclusive"},{"test":"kimura-heterozygosity","clade":"Mammalia","held_out_n":40,"builder_min_n":50,"verdict":"inconclusive"},{"test":"hamilton-senescence","clade":"Aves","held_out_n":8,"builder_min_n":15,"verdict":"inconclusive"},{"test":"hamilton-senescence","clade":"Mammalia","held_out_n":20,"builder_min_n":15,"verdict":"mixed"}],"decisive_exams_by_clade":{"Aves":0,"Mammalia":1},"tests_post_hoc_if_mammalia":["kimura-heterozygosity","hamilton-senescence","thompson1917-ch16-13"],"mammal_only_tests":["thompson1917-ch16-13"]}},"first_frozen_at":"2026-10-31T05:52:44.982Z","previous_freeze":{"frozen_at":"2026-10-31T05:52:44.982Z","provisional":true,"exam_json_sha256":"06b797929a27fad5b7173dbaa0c2d9d297deea478a64b7a7935f85caec430360","roster_unchanged":true,"superseded_because":"clade confirmed; provisional flag cleared and the decision recorded"},"rule":["An organism is held out when the inventory's lineage puts it in class Aves (any rank: species, genus, family, order, or the class itself).","The rule is the class, not the list: a bird species that is not in the inventory is held out too.","A taxon above class rank that contains Aves (Animalia, Metazoa, Eumetazoa, Bilateria, Deuterostomia, Chordata, Vertebrata, Craniata, Gnathostomata, Osteichthyes, Sarcopterygii, Tetrapoda, Amniota, Sauropsida, Diapsida, Archosauria, Dinosauria, Theropoda) is excluded from both sides, because its data mixes them.","Everything else is available for building (train).","Genome-ready means the best NCBI assembly is chromosome-level or a complete genome. NCBI's reference flag alone is not enough, because it also marks scaffold-level and contig-level assemblies."],"rules_for_builders":["Do not fit, tune, select or sanity-check anything on data for a bird: no Aves rows from trait tables, genomes, occurrence counts, fossils, or claim texts that only Aves organisms support.","A claim test's planned_datasets may name a shared table (AnAge, EltonTraits, the Amniote database) only with the held-out class filtered out, and the filter must be in the committed analysis script.","The exam is run once, after building stops, on the frozen roster below. The roster’s SHA-256 is in CHECKSUMS.json; node holdout/make-split.mjs --verify checks it.","Reading this file is allowed. It names organisms, identifiers and which tables cover them; it contains no trait values."],"what_is_tested":"Each candidate law that a builder supports on training organisms is re-scored, by an assessor who did not build it, on the held-out species below, using the same pre-registered pass and fail criteria. A law counts as generalizing only if it passes here.","frozen_at":"2026-10-31T14:38:42.937Z","checksums":{"clade":"Aves","provisional":false,"decision":{"status":"confirmed","decided_by":"Amit Shenoy, project lead, in his own words to the hub: \"Sure do AVes\"","decided_on":"2026-10-31"},"inputs":{"organisms/merged/taxa.json":{"sha256":"ac23df282cda36e20063fe3bdb2bd0519c8d8a2cad2618f4d1180083155480a8","bytes":480067},"organisms/merged/datasets.json":{"sha256":"c00121bc96e727fc9cc547b55faf9523ed54cd88042f74c400106e944e35b2f3","bytes":1994139},"dashboard/genomes.cache.json":{"sha256":"117eef84636b8d2e05f32a1388672899cea98c9e63de729ed01513dfb612b366","bytes":53410},"docs/claims.json":{"sha256":"da6ba24af6efe5f0eafdc16790ec85947c4e14d71ea9609f5ce9f9f3f4fe8581","bytes":1063673}},"outputs":{"split.json":{"sha256":"d73dab71347e21e047ea2304b3ae669ed08b780b515aeba249097545246c0855","bytes":282269},"exam.json":{"sha256":"f59b7b8ca2bdee21960f6a773de60967bc5c2933ffc75ee9da64e089228f5c7e","bytes":36005},"holdout-taxa.csv":{"sha256":"f149873b96d8359a310d32ca55874b63e7547f1df04c856d5dfb9b95ed9dd134","bytes":16088}},"roster_sha256":"9c4499751d6fa58502e9959e23ead955b1338f2dc84eb5fa24a61548d89277c3","generator":"holdout/make-split.mjs","frozen_at":"2026-10-31T14:38:42.937Z","first_frozen_at":"2026-10-31T05:52:44.982Z","previous_freeze":{"frozen_at":"2026-10-31T05:52:44.982Z","provisional":true,"outputs":{"split.json":{"sha256":"1e57dabb9cb49dbf6dee0f007421d1d095cec86e4d1fe879e1ebde1166dea94a","bytes":279981},"exam.json":{"sha256":"06b797929a27fad5b7173dbaa0c2d9d297deea478a64b7a7935f85caec430360","bytes":33717},"holdout-taxa.csv":{"sha256":"f149873b96d8359a310d32ca55874b63e7547f1df04c856d5dfb9b95ed9dd134","bytes":16088}},"roster_sha256":"9c4499751d6fa58502e9959e23ead955b1338f2dc84eb5fa24a61548d89277c3","roster_unchanged":true,"superseded_because":"clade confirmed; provisional flag cleared and the decision recorded","history":[]}},"summary":{"taxa":363,"holdout":88,"train":273,"excluded":2,"holdout_species":48,"holdout_species_with_assembly":43,"holdout_species_genome_ready":35,"holdout_species_reference_flag_but_not_ready":8,"holdout_species_no_assembly":5,"holdout_species_with_trait_table":48,"holdout_species_exam_ready":35,"holdout_mentions":368,"holdout_higher_taxa":40,"claims":{"mixed":13,"no-organism":782,"holdout":12,"train":72,"excluded-only":1},"trait_sources":{"avonet":25,"amniote":40,"anage":38,"eltontraits":45}},"alt":{"clade":"Mammalia","summary":{"taxa":363,"holdout":105,"train":257,"excluded":1,"holdout_species":43,"holdout_species_with_assembly":38,"holdout_species_genome_ready":31,"holdout_species_reference_flag_but_not_ready":7,"holdout_species_no_assembly":5,"holdout_species_with_trait_table":40,"holdout_species_exam_ready":29,"holdout_mentions":563,"holdout_higher_taxa":62,"claims":{"train":57,"no-organism":782,"holdout":25,"mixed":15,"excluded-only":1},"trait_sources":{"pantheria":39,"amniote":34,"anage":38,"eltontraits":39}}},"byClass":{"Aves":{"holdout":88,"train":0,"excluded":0},"Insecta":{"holdout":0,"train":57,"excluded":0},"Actinopterygii":{"holdout":0,"train":6,"excluded":0},"Crocodylia":{"holdout":0,"train":1,"excluded":0},"Malacostraca":{"holdout":0,"train":11,"excluded":0},"Cephalopoda":{"holdout":0,"train":3,"excluded":0},"(Chordata, no class)":{"holdout":0,"train":9,"excluded":1},"Gastropoda":{"holdout":0,"train":6,"excluded":0},"(Annelida, no class)":{"holdout":0,"train":1,"excluded":0},"Amphibia":{"holdout":0,"train":8,"excluded":0},"Mammalia":{"holdout":0,"train":105,"excluded":0},"Arachnida":{"holdout":0,"train":3,"excluded":0},"Branchiopoda":{"holdout":0,"train":4,"excluded":0},"(Arthropoda, no class)":{"holdout":0,"train":3,"excluded":0},"Maxillopoda":{"holdout":0,"train":6,"excluded":0},"Chondrichthyes":{"holdout":0,"train":2,"excluded":0},"Hydrozoa":{"holdout":0,"train":10,"excluded":0},"(no class)":{"holdout":0,"train":1,"excluded":0},"(Mollusca, no class)":{"holdout":0,"train":2,"excluded":0},"Pilidiophora":{"holdout":0,"train":1,"excluded":0},"Anthozoa":{"holdout":0,"train":2,"excluded":0},"Polychaeta":{"holdout":0,"train":1,"excluded":0},"Polyplacophora":{"holdout":0,"train":1,"excluded":0},"Thecostraca":{"holdout":0,"train":2,"excluded":0},"Copepoda":{"holdout":0,"train":1,"excluded":0},"Reptilia":{"holdout":0,"train":8,"excluded":1},"Squamata":{"holdout":0,"train":2,"excluded":0},"(Echinodermata, no class)":{"holdout":0,"train":1,"excluded":0},"Echinoidea":{"holdout":0,"train":3,"excluded":0},"Clitellata":{"holdout":0,"train":2,"excluded":0},"Dipneusti":{"holdout":0,"train":2,"excluded":0},"Lingulata":{"holdout":0,"train":1,"excluded":0},"Elasmobranchii":{"holdout":0,"train":1,"excluded":0},"Bivalvia":{"holdout":0,"train":3,"excluded":0},"Chromadorea":{"holdout":0,"train":1,"excluded":0},"(Porifera, no class)":{"holdout":0,"train":1,"excluded":0},"(Rotifera, no class)":{"holdout":0,"train":1,"excluded":0},"Turbellaria":{"holdout":0,"train":1,"excluded":0}},"levels":{"Complete Genome":1,"Chromosome":34,"Scaffold":8,"no assembly":5},"roster":[{"key":"gbif:9761484","name":"Anas platyrhynchos","rank":"species","order":"Anseriformes","family":"Anatidae","ids":{"gbif":9761484,"ncbi":8839,"wikidata":"Q25348"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_047663525.1","best_level":"Complete Genome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":true,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":8,"claims":3},{"key":"gbif:2498036","name":"Anser anser","rank":"species","order":"Anseriformes","family":"Anatidae","ids":{"gbif":2498036,"ncbi":8843,"wikidata":"Q25882"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_964211835.1","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":true,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":7,"claims":0},{"key":"gbif:2498034","name":"Anser cygnoides","rank":"species","order":"Anseriformes","family":"Anatidae","ids":{"gbif":2498034,"ncbi":8845,"wikidata":"Q31354"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_040182565.1","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":true,"amniote":true,"anage":false,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":1,"claims":0},{"key":"gbif:5228676","name":"Apus apus","rank":"species","order":"Apodiformes","family":"Apodidae","ids":{"gbif":5228676,"ncbi":8895,"wikidata":"Q25377"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_020740795.1","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":true,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":1,"claims":0},{"key":"gbif:2494686","name":"Carduelis carduelis","rank":"species","order":"Passeriformes","family":"Fringillidae","ids":{"gbif":2494686,"ncbi":37600,"wikidata":"Q25418"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_987197145.1","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":true,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":1,"claims":0},{"key":"gbif:5232428","name":"Chloephaga picta","rank":"species","order":"Anseriformes","family":"Anatidae","ids":{"gbif":5232428,"ncbi":8861,"wikidata":"Q129036"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_056318165.1","best_level":"Scaffold","ready":false},"traits":{"avonet":false,"amniote":true,"anage":false,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":5,"claims":4},{"key":"gbif:2495093","name":"Cinclus cinclus","rank":"species","order":"Passeriformes","family":"Cinclidae","ids":{"gbif":2495093,"ncbi":127875,"wikidata":"Q201831"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_963662255.1","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":false,"amniote":false,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":2,"claims":2},{"key":"gbif:2478233","name":"Colaptes campestris","rank":"species","order":"Piciformes","family":"Picidae","ids":{"gbif":2478233,"ncbi":555237,"wikidata":"Q1274176"},"genome":{"best_accession":null,"best_level":null,"ready":false},"traits":{"avonet":false,"amniote":false,"anage":false,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":1,"claims":1},{"key":"gbif:2495414","name":"Columba livia","rank":"species","order":"Columbiformes","family":"Columbidae","ids":{"gbif":2495414,"ncbi":8932,"wikidata":"Q42326"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_036013475.2","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":true,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":71,"claims":13},{"key":"gbif:2495471","name":"Columba oenas","rank":"species","order":"Columbiformes","family":"Columbidae","ids":{"gbif":2495471,"ncbi":160229,"wikidata":"Q26140"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_062014566.1","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":false,"amniote":false,"anage":true,"eltontraits":false},"mentions":1,"claims":0},{"key":"gbif:2482515","name":"Corvus cornix","rank":"species","order":"Passeriformes","family":"Corvidae","ids":{"gbif":2482515,"ncbi":181096,"wikidata":"Q25405"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_000738735.6","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":true,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":false},"mentions":1,"claims":0},{"key":"gbif:2474156","name":"Coturnix coturnix","rank":"species","order":"Galliformes","family":"Phasianidae","ids":{"gbif":2474156,"ncbi":9091,"wikidata":"Q28358"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_051820755.1","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":true,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":2,"claims":2},{"key":"gbif:4408498","name":"Crex crex","rank":"species","order":"Gruiformes","family":"Rallidae","ids":{"gbif":4408498,"ncbi":185586,"wikidata":"Q26017"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_987197635.1","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":false,"amniote":false,"anage":false,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":2,"claims":2},{"key":"gbif:5231918","name":"Cuculus canorus","rank":"species","order":"Cuculiformes","family":"Cuculidae","ids":{"gbif":5231918,"ncbi":55661,"wikidata":"Q18845"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_017976375.1","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":true,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":12,"claims":1},{"key":"gbif:2495134","name":"Dromaius novaehollandiae","rank":"species","order":"Casuariiformes","family":"Dromaiidae","ids":{"gbif":2495134,"ncbi":8790,"wikidata":"Q93208"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_036370855.1","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":true,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":1,"claims":1},{"key":"gbif:2481433","name":"Fulmarus glacialis","rank":"species","order":"Procellariiformes","family":"Procellariidae","ids":{"gbif":2481433,"ncbi":30455,"wikidata":"Q26896"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_000690835.1","best_level":"Scaffold","ready":false},"traits":{"avonet":false,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":1,"claims":0},{"key":"gbif:2481819","name":"Gallinago gallinago","rank":"species","order":"Charadriiformes","family":"Scolopacidae","ids":{"gbif":2481819,"ncbi":107377,"wikidata":"Q25692"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_986504185.1","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":false,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":1,"claims":0},{"key":"gbif:5228199","name":"Gallinula chloropus","rank":"species","order":"Gruiformes","family":"Rallidae","ids":{"gbif":5228199,"ncbi":9123,"wikidata":"Q18847"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_964237585.1","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":false,"amniote":false,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":1,"claims":1},{"key":"gbif:9326020","name":"Gallus gallus","rank":"species","order":"Galliformes","family":"Phasianidae","ids":{"gbif":9326020,"ncbi":9031,"wikidata":"Q184774"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_016699485.1","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":true,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":27,"claims":2},{"key":"gbif:2473421","name":"Lagopus lagopus","rank":"species","order":"Galliformes","family":"Phasianidae","ids":{"gbif":2473421,"ncbi":52650,"wikidata":"Q178702"},"genome":{"best_accession":null,"best_level":null,"ready":false},"traits":{"avonet":false,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":3,"claims":1},{"key":"gbif:5227679","name":"Lagopus muta","rank":"species","order":"Galliformes","family":"Phasianidae","ids":{"gbif":5227679,"ncbi":64668,"wikidata":"Q205930"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_023343835.1","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":false,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":2,"claims":1},{"key":"gbif:2473682","name":"Lyrurus tetrix","rank":"species","order":"Galliformes","family":"Phasianidae","ids":{"gbif":2473682,"ncbi":1233216,"wikidata":"Q155878"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_043882375.1","best_level":"Scaffold","ready":false},"traits":{"avonet":false,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":false},"mentions":2,"claims":1},{"key":"gbif:9606290","name":"Meleagris gallopavo","rank":"species","order":"Galliformes","family":"Phasianidae","ids":{"gbif":9606290,"ncbi":9103,"wikidata":"Q26844"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_905368555.5","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":true,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":4,"claims":2},{"key":"gbif:5788812","name":"Mimus melanotis","rank":"species","order":"Passeriformes","family":"Mimidae","ids":{"gbif":5788812,"ncbi":245851,"wikidata":"Q2669171"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_042985785.1","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":true,"amniote":true,"anage":false,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":1,"claims":2},{"key":"gbif:5788813","name":"Mimus trifasciatus","rank":"species","order":"Passeriformes","family":"Mimidae","ids":{"gbif":5788813,"ncbi":245847,"wikidata":"Q3285195"},"genome":{"best_accession":null,"best_level":null,"ready":false},"traits":{"avonet":true,"amniote":true,"anage":false,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":1,"claims":2},{"key":"gbif:2473341","name":"Numida meleagris","rank":"species","order":"Galliformes","family":"Numididae","ids":{"gbif":2473341,"ncbi":8996,"wikidata":"Q251842"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_002078875.2","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":false,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":1,"claims":0},{"key":"gbif:9705453","name":"Parus major","rank":"species","order":"Passeriformes","family":"Paridae","ids":{"gbif":9705453,"ncbi":9157,"wikidata":"Q25485"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_001522545.3","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":false,"amniote":false,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":1,"claims":1},{"key":"gbif:5231190","name":"Passer domesticus","rank":"species","order":"Passeriformes","family":"Passeridae","ids":{"gbif":5231190,"ncbi":48849,"wikidata":"Q14683"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_036417665.1","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":true,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":2,"claims":1},{"key":"gbif:9451184","name":"Pavo cristatus","rank":"species","order":"Galliformes","family":"Phasianidae","ids":{"gbif":9451184,"ncbi":9049,"wikidata":"Q61865"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_045791835.1","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":false,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":3,"claims":0},{"key":"gbif:2473958","name":"Perdix perdix","rank":"species","order":"Galliformes","family":"Phasianidae","ids":{"gbif":2473958,"ncbi":9052,"wikidata":"Q26106"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_987270415.1","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":true,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":3,"claims":2},{"key":"gbif:9752149","name":"Phasianus colchicus","rank":"species","order":"Galliformes","family":"Phasianidae","ids":{"gbif":9752149,"ncbi":9054,"wikidata":"Q25432"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_004143745.1","best_level":"Scaffold","ready":false},"traits":{"avonet":true,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":2,"claims":0},{"key":"gbif:5227775","name":"Phasianus versicolor","rank":"species","order":"Galliformes","family":"Phasianidae","ids":{"gbif":5227775,"ncbi":9055,"wikidata":"Q425900"},"genome":{"best_accession":null,"best_level":null,"ready":false},"traits":{"avonet":true,"amniote":true,"anage":false,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":1,"claims":0},{"key":"gbif:5229490","name":"Pica pica","rank":"species","order":"Passeriformes","family":"Corvidae","ids":{"gbif":5229490,"ncbi":34924,"wikidata":"Q25307"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_987212955.1","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":true,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":1,"claims":0},{"key":"gbif:2478523","name":"Picus viridis","rank":"species","order":"Piciformes","family":"Picidae","ids":{"gbif":2478523,"ncbi":100825,"wikidata":"Q166171"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_033816785.1","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":false,"amniote":false,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":1,"claims":1},{"key":"gbif:2482755","name":"Pitangus sulphuratus","rank":"species","order":"Passeriformes","family":"Tyrannidae","ids":{"gbif":2482755,"ncbi":371930,"wikidata":"Q202804"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_029286575.1","best_level":"Scaffold","ready":false},"traits":{"avonet":false,"amniote":false,"anage":false,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":1,"claims":1},{"key":"gbif:2494543","name":"Pyrrhula pyrrhula","rank":"species","order":"Passeriformes","family":"Fringillidae","ids":{"gbif":2494543,"ncbi":37607,"wikidata":"Q25382"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_987196105.1","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":true,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":1,"claims":0},{"key":"gbif:2495165","name":"Rhea americana","rank":"species","order":"Rheiformes","family":"Rheidae","ids":{"gbif":2495165,"ncbi":8797,"wikidata":"Q192044"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_003343005.1","best_level":"Scaffold","ready":false},"traits":{"avonet":true,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":4,"claims":1},{"key":"gbif:2495160","name":"Rhea pennata","rank":"species","order":"Rheiformes","family":"Rheidae","ids":{"gbif":2495160,"ncbi":8795,"wikidata":"Q733120"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_028389875.1","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":true,"amniote":true,"anage":false,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":1,"claims":1},{"key":"gbif:5230373","name":"Rupicola rupicola","rank":"species","order":"Passeriformes","family":"Cotingidae","ids":{"gbif":5230373,"ncbi":81879,"wikidata":"Q652466"},"genome":{"best_accession":null,"best_level":null,"ready":false},"traits":{"avonet":false,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":1,"claims":0},{"key":"gbif:2481700","name":"Scolopax rusticola","rank":"species","order":"Charadriiformes","family":"Scolopacidae","ids":{"gbif":2481700,"ncbi":100826,"wikidata":"Q26114"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_964304615.2","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":false,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":1,"claims":0},{"key":"gbif:2494303","name":"Serinus canaria","rank":"species","order":"Passeriformes","family":"Fringillidae","ids":{"gbif":2494303,"ncbi":9135,"wikidata":"Q192524"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_022539315.2","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":true,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":2,"claims":0},{"key":"gbif:2495150","name":"Struthio camelus","rank":"species","order":"Struthioniformes","family":"Struthionidae","ids":{"gbif":2495150,"ncbi":8801,"wikidata":"Q17592"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_040807025.1","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":true,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":8,"claims":5},{"key":"gbif:2498233","name":"Tachyeres brachypterus","rank":"species","order":"Anseriformes","family":"Anatidae","ids":{"gbif":2498233,"ncbi":658925,"wikidata":"Q287092"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_032357605.1","best_level":"Scaffold","ready":false},"traits":{"avonet":false,"amniote":true,"anage":false,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":1,"claims":0},{"key":"gbif:5231438","name":"Troglodytes troglodytes","rank":"species","order":"Passeriformes","family":"Troglodytidae","ids":{"gbif":5231438,"ncbi":36278,"wikidata":"Q25740"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_987195935.1","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":true,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":1,"claims":0},{"key":"gbif:2490719","name":"Turdus merula","rank":"species","order":"Passeriformes","family":"Turdidae","ids":{"gbif":2490719,"ncbi":9187,"wikidata":"Q25234"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_965287015.2","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":false,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":1,"claims":0},{"key":"gbif:7901064","name":"Turdus philomelos","rank":"species","order":"Passeriformes","family":"Turdidae","ids":{"gbif":7901064,"ncbi":127946,"wikidata":"Q26349"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_965287025.1","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":false,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":1,"claims":0},{"key":"gbif:2490774","name":"Turdus viscivorus","rank":"species","order":"Passeriformes","family":"Turdidae","ids":{"gbif":2490774,"ncbi":301543,"wikidata":"Q178942"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_982555985.1","best_level":"Scaffold","ready":false},"traits":{"avonet":false,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":1,"claims":0},{"key":"gbif:2481907","name":"Vultur gryphus","rank":"species","order":"Accipitriformes","family":"Cathartidae","ids":{"gbif":2481907,"ncbi":8924,"wikidata":"Q170598"},"genome":{"best_accession":"GCA_039700855.2","best_level":"Chromosome","ready":true},"traits":{"avonet":false,"amniote":true,"anage":true,"eltontraits":true},"mentions":1,"claims":0}],"higher":[{"key":"gbif:2877","name":"Accipitridae","rank":"family"},{"key":"gbif:7191147","name":"Accipitriformes","rank":"order"},{"key":"gbif:2984","name":"Alcedinidae","rank":"family"},{"key":"gbif:2985","name":"Alcidae","rank":"family"},{"key":"gbif:2986","name":"Anatidae","rank":"family"},{"key":"gbif:2495138","name":"Apteryx","rank":"genus"},{"key":"gbif:2480498","name":"Aquila","rank":"genus"},{"key":"gbif:3685","name":"Ardeidae","rank":"family"},{"key":"gbif:212","name":"Aves","rank":"class"},{"key":"gbif:2487601","name":"Certhia","rank":"genus"},{"key":"gbif:7192402","name":"Charadriiformes","rank":"order"},{"key":"gbif:9289","name":"Ciconiidae","rank":"family"},{"key":"gbif:2496285","name":"Coccyzus","rank":"genus"},{"key":"gbif:5233","name":"Columbidae","rank":"family"},{"key":"wd:Q452969","name":"Dinornithiformes","rank":"order"},{"key":"gbif:2480996","name":"Falco","rank":"genus"},{"key":"gbif:2480184","name":"Fregata","rank":"genus"},{"key":"gbif:5242","name":"Fringillidae","rank":"family"},{"key":"gbif:2474376","name":"Fulica","rank":"genus"},{"key":"gbif:723","name":"Galliformes","rank":"order"},{"key":"gbif:5248","name":"Hirundinidae","rank":"family"},{"key":"gbif:9315","name":"Laniidae","rank":"family"},{"key":"gbif:2494919","name":"Mimus","rank":"genus"},{"key":"gbif:9610","name":"Otididae","rank":"family"},{"key":"gbif:5711","name":"Paradisaeidae","rank":"family"},{"key":"gbif:2481417","name":"Pelecanoides","rank":"genus"},{"key":"gbif:10650925","name":"Pelecanus","rank":"genus"},{"key":"gbif:9333","name":"Picidae","rank":"family"},{"key":"gbif:9338","name":"Podicipedidae","rank":"family"},{"key":"gbif:7192755","name":"Procellariiformes","rank":"order"},{"key":"gbif:2495164","name":"Rhea","rank":"genus"},{"key":"gbif:2484878","name":"Sitta","rank":"genus"},{"key":"gbif:5284","name":"Spheniscidae","rank":"family"},{"key":"gbif:1450","name":"Strigiformes","rank":"order"},{"key":"gbif:2498232","name":"Tachyeres","rank":"genus"},{"key":"wd:Q201240","name":"Tetraoninae","rank":"subfamily"},{"key":"gbif:5289","name":"Trochilidae","rank":"family"},{"key":"gbif:2493899","name":"Troglodytes","rank":"genus"},{"key":"gbif:5290","name":"Turdidae","rank":"family"},{"key":"gbif:2490714","name":"Turdus","rank":"genus"}],"excluded":[{"name":"Dinosauria","rank":"clade","reason":"ranks above Aves and contains it, so its data mixes held-out and training organisms"},{"name":"Vertebrata","rank":"subphylum","reason":"ranks above Aves and contains it, so its data mixes held-out and training organisms"}],"claims":[{"id":"darwin1859-intro-01","side":"mixed","label":"External conditions alone cannot explain complex coadaptations","kind":"mechanism","holdout_taxa":["gbif:9333"]},{"id":"darwin1859-ch01-04","side":"holdout","label":"Inherited effects of use and disuse modify domestic animals","kind":"mechanism","holdout_taxa":["gbif:9761484"]},{"id":"darwin1859-ch01-10","side":"holdout","label":"All domestic pigeon breeds descend from the rock-pigeon","kind":"historical-inference","holdout_taxa":["gbif:2495414"]},{"id":"darwin1859-ch04-04","side":"mixed","label":"Protective colours matching backgrounds are maintained by selection","kind":"mechanism","holdout_taxa":["gbif:2473421","gbif:5227679","gbif:2473682"]},{"id":"darwin1859-ch04-07","side":"holdout","label":"Female choice over many generations can produce male ornaments","kind":"mechanism","holdout_taxa":["gbif:212"]},{"id":"darwin1859-ch05-03","side":"holdout","label":"Flightlessness of birds on predator-free oceanic islands is caused by disuse","kind":"mechanism","holdout_taxa":["gbif:212"]},{"id":"darwin1859-ch07-04","side":"holdout","label":"Instincts vary within species in a state of nature","kind":"empirical-generalization","holdout_taxa":["gbif:212"]},{"id":"darwin1859-ch07-05","side":"holdout","label":"Fear of man is acquired slowly by animals exposed to human persecution","kind":"empirical-generalization","holdout_taxa":["gbif:212"]},{"id":"darwin1859-ch07-07","side":"holdout","label":"Cuckoo brood parasitism evolved from occasional laying in other birds’ nests","kind":"historical-inference","holdout_taxa":["gbif:212","gbif:5231918"]},{"id":"darwin1859-ch08-09","side":"holdout","label":"Early embryo death is a frequent cause of sterility in first crosses","kind":"empirical-generalization","holdout_taxa":["gbif:723"]},{"id":"darwin1859-ch11-03","side":"mixed","label":"Species of the same continent or sea are related despite differing stations","kind":"empirical-generalization","holdout_taxa":["gbif:212","gbif:2495134","gbif:2495164","gbif:2495165","gbif:2495160","gbif:2495150"]},{"id":"darwin1859-ch11-10","side":"mixed","label":"Occasional transport bridges hundreds of miles but not distant continents","kind":"mechanism","holdout_taxa":["gbif:2877","gbif:7191147","gbif:212","gbif:9289","gbif:2495414","gbif:2474156","gbif:9606290","gbif:10650925","gbif:2473958","gbif:1450"]},{"id":"darwin1859-ch12-03","side":"mixed","label":"Water birds disperse seeds and eggs, explaining wide ranges of fresh-water life","kind":"mechanism","holdout_taxa":["gbif:9761484","gbif:3685","gbif:212","gbif:7192402"]},{"id":"darwin1859-ch12-05","side":"mixed","label":"Oceanic islands have a very high proportion of endemic species","kind":"empirical-generalization","holdout_taxa":["gbif:212"]},{"id":"darwin1859-ch12-06","side":"mixed","label":"Island endemism is low in groups that arrive easily and in numbers","kind":"mechanism","holdout_taxa":["gbif:212","gbif:7192402"]},{"id":"darwin1859-ch12-09","side":"mixed","label":"No native terrestrial mammals on islands more than 300 miles from a continent","kind":"empirical-generalization","holdout_taxa":["wd:Q452969"]},{"id":"darwin1859-ch12-12","side":"holdout","label":"Island endemics are related to species of the nearest continent","kind":"empirical-generalization","holdout_taxa":["gbif:212"]},{"id":"darwin1859-ch12-13","side":"mixed","label":"Species on islands of one archipelago are closest relatives of each other","kind":"empirical-generalization","holdout_taxa":["gbif:212","gbif:2494919","gbif:5788812","gbif:5788813"]},{"id":"darwin1859-ch12-14","side":"mixed","label":"Naturalised species are usually not closely allied to the natives they join","kind":"empirical-generalization","holdout_taxa":["gbif:212","gbif:2494919","gbif:5788812","gbif:5788813"]},{"id":"darwin1859-ch12-15","side":"mixed","label":"Inhabitants of any area are modified colonists from the most accessible source","kind":"historical-inference","holdout_taxa":["gbif:5289"]},{"id":"darwin1859-ch13-12","side":"holdout","label":"Gaps between groups, even whole classes, are due to extinction of connecting forms","kind":"historical-inference","holdout_taxa":["gbif:212"]},{"id":"darwin1859-ch13-18","side":"mixed","label":"Young of domestic breeds differ much less than adults","kind":"empirical-generalization","holdout_taxa":["gbif:2495414"]},{"id":"darwin1859-ch13-25","side":"holdout","label":"Disuse is the main cause of rudimentary organs","kind":"mechanism","holdout_taxa":["gbif:212"]},{"id":"thompson1917-ch02-06","side":"holdout","label":"Power needed for flight grows as length^3.5 while muscle power grows as length^3","kind":"mathematical-law","holdout_taxa":["gbif:212","gbif:5231190","gbif:2495150"]},{"id":"thompson1917-ch02-07","side":"mixed","label":"Ostrich and moa have passed the size at which muscular flight is possible","kind":"prediction","holdout_taxa":["wd:Q452969","gbif:2495150"]}],"burned":[{"id":"darwin1859-ch01-10","label":"All domestic pigeon breeds descend from the rock-pigeon","why":"In the swarm comparison's frozen 20-claim set (swarm/PREREG.md); the four arms had started before Aves was held out. Columba livia is on the roster.","disclosed_by":"swarm thread (scienceclaw-3d), swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md, 2026-10-31","in_claims_mentioning_holdout":true},{"id":"thompson1917-ch15-01","label":"Eggs are prolate spheroids, never oblate","why":"In the same swarm comparison set; about birds by subject although the inventory links it to no bird taxon, so check-leaks.mjs does not flag it.","disclosed_by":"swarm thread (scienceclaw-3d), swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md, 2026-10-31","in_claims_mentioning_holdout":false}],"examResults":[{"file":"holdout/exam-results/math-bio-theorems/hamilton-senescence/result.json","claim_id":"hamilton-senescence","builder_result":"claim-tests/math-bio-theorems/hamilton-senescence/result.json","builder_verdict":"mixed","builder_measured":{"value":0.5714285714285714,"unit":"fraction of qualifying non-bird species with Spearman rho(age, adult mortality) > 0","n":"35 species (classes: {'Mammalia': 20, 'Actinopterygii': 9, 'Amphibia': 2, 'Reptilia': 2, 'Bivalvia': 1, 'Gastropoda': 1})"},"exam_measured":{"value":0.625,"unit":"fraction of held-out bird species with Spearman rho(age, adult mortality) > 0","n":8,"extra":{"rising":5,"falling":2,"flat":1,"mean_spearman_rho":0.08174827223593134}},"exam_verdict":"inconclusive","reason":"underpowered: 8 bird species, the pre-registered rule needs 15","agrees":null,"date":"2026-10-31","leak_check_exit":0},{"file":"holdout/exam-results/math-bio-theorems/kimura-heterozygosity/result.json","claim_id":"kimura-heterozygosity","builder_result":"claim-tests/math-bio-theorems/kimura-heterozygosity/result.json","builder_verdict":"refutes","builder_measured":{"value":0.10731485075894663,"unit":"OLS slope of log10(pi) on log10(census N); the law with Ne proportional to N predicts about 1","n":"160 non-bird metazoan species (diversity sources: {'Leffler et al.': 90, 'Romiguier et al.': 58, 'Corbett-Detig et al.': 12})"},"exam_measured":{"value":0.06858780076164865,"unit":"OLS slope of log10(pi) on log10(census N) among held-out bird species only","n":13,"extra":{"spearman_rho_birds":0.5384615384615384,"bird_mean_residual_from_non_bird_fit":-0.047751058889177085,"non_bird_fit":{"slope":0.10731485075894677,"ci95":[0.07771085302172728,0.13691884849616626],"n":160}}},"exam_verdict":"inconclusive","reason":"underpowered: 13 bird species, the pre-registered rule needs 50","agrees":null,"date":"2026-10-31","leak_check_exit":0},{"file":"holdout/exam-results/organism-design/result.run2.json","claim_id":"organism-design text-to-blueprint, Aves roster","builder_result":"organism-design/exam/aves-predictions.json","builder_verdict":"n/a (blueprint tool)","builder_measured":{"value":"2 distinct vectors","unit":"exploratory: distinct prediction vectors across the 48 roster species (not pre-registered)","n":48},"exam_measured":{"value":"A keel: 0 scored; B webbing: 0 scored; C conflicts: not reported","unit":"pre-registered tests A, B, C (PREREG.md)","n":48,"extra":{"distinct_prediction_vectors_across_roster":2,"species_with_predictions":48,"panel_structures":259,"panel_terms_matching_keel":[],"panel_terms_matching_webbing":[],"predictions_by_confidence":{"present_stated":5664,"present_default":1485,"absent":5283}}},"exam_verdict":"inconclusive","reason":"the panel contains no sternal-keel term, so test A has no predictions to score the panel contains no foot-webbing term, so test B has no predictions to score the prediction file reports no reading.conflicts, so test C is not evaluable","agrees":null,"date":"2026-10-31","leak_check_exit":0}],"notApplicable":[{"claim_id":"darwin1859-ch09-03","builder_result":"claim-tests/darwin-origin/darwin1859-ch09-03/result.json","builder_verdict":"refutes","why_not_applicable":"International Chronostratigraphic Chart boundary ages (Macrostrat API): geological time, no organisms","checked":"2026-10-31"},{"claim_id":"darwin1859-ch11-13","builder_result":"claim-tests/darwin-origin/darwin1859-ch11-13/result.json","builder_verdict":"supports","why_not_applicable":"LR04 benthic d18O stack and EPICA Dome C temperature: climate series, no organisms","checked":"2026-10-31"},{"claim_id":"thompson1917-ch03-07","builder_result":"claim-tests/thompson-growth-form/thompson1917-ch03-07/result.json","builder_verdict":"supports","why_not_applicable":"NHANES body measures: Homo sapiens only (a training organism), no held-out rows possible","checked":"2026-10-31"},{"claim_id":"thompson1917-ch04-13","builder_result":"claim-tests/thompson-growth-form/thompson1917-ch04-13/result.json","builder_verdict":"refutes","why_not_applicable":"Chromosome Counts Database: plants only; the one leak-check hit (Troglodytes) is a plant genus homonym and is allowlisted","checked":"2026-10-31"},{"claim_id":"fisher-infinitesimal","builder_result":"claim-tests/math-bio-theorems/fisher-infinitesimal/result.json","builder_verdict":"supports","why_not_applicable":"Galton 1886 family heights (HistData GaltonFamilies): Homo sapiens only, a training organism; no held-out rows possible","checked":"2026-10-31"},{"claim_id":"fisher-sex-ratio","builder_result":"claim-tests/math-bio-theorems/fisher-sex-ratio/result.json","builder_verdict":"mixed","why_not_applicable":"UN World Population Prospects 2024 sex ratio at birth: Homo sapiens country-years only; no held-out rows possible","checked":"2026-10-31"},{"claim_id":"hamilton-lmc","builder_result":"claim-tests/math-bio-theorems/hamilton-lmc/result.json","builder_verdict":"inconclusive","why_not_applicable":"Nasonia vitripennis (parasitoid wasp) sex-allocation data on Dryad, download blocked (HTTP 403), nothing measured; an insect, outside both candidate clades","checked":"2026-10-31"},{"claim_id":"kimura-fixation-probability","builder_result":"claim-tests/math-bio-theorems/kimura-fixation-probability/result.json","builder_verdict":"supports","why_not_applicable":"Buri 1956 Drosophila melanogaster bw75 allele counts: one insect species, outside both candidate clades","checked":"2026-10-31"},{"claim_id":"maynardsmith-hitchhiking","builder_result":"claim-tests/math-bio-theorems/maynardsmith-hitchhiking/result.json","builder_verdict":"supports","why_not_applicable":"1000 Genomes Phase 3 chromosome 22 and HapMap recombination map: Homo sapiens only, a training organism","checked":"2026-10-31"},{"claim_id":"maynardsmith-war-of-attrition","builder_result":"claim-tests/math-bio-theorems/maynardsmith-war-of-attrition/result.json","builder_verdict":"inconclusive","why_not_applicable":"Spider contest-display durations on Dryad, download blocked (HTTP 403), nothing measured; an arachnid, outside both candidate clades","checked":"2026-10-31"},{"claim_id":"thompson1917-ch03-10","builder_result":"claim-tests/thompson-growth-form/thompson1917-ch03-10/result.json","builder_verdict":"mixed","why_not_applicable":"ICES DATRAS North Sea bottom-trawl age data: 11 fish species, no birds; fish are training organisms under either candidate clade","checked":"2026-10-31"},{"claim_id":"thompson1917-ch10-02","builder_result":"claim-tests/thompson-growth-form/thompson1917-ch10-02/result.json","builder_verdict":"refutes","why_not_applicable":"Pandita et al. 2013 Turritellidae shell biometrics: 4 gastropod species, 34 specimens; molluscs, outside both candidate clades","checked":"2026-10-31"},{"claim_id":"thompson1917-ch11-06","builder_result":"claim-tests/thompson-growth-form/thompson1917-ch11-06/result.json","builder_verdict":"refutes","why_not_applicable":"Walton and Korn 2018 ammonoid conch ontogeny (Dryad): extinct cephalopods, outside both candidate clades","checked":"2026-10-31"},{"claim_id":"thompson1917-ch16-13","builder_result":"claim-tests/thompson-growth-form/thompson1917-ch16-13/result.json","builder_verdict":"supports","why_not_applicable":"Figueirido et al. 2021 carnivoran vertebrae and cetacean vertebral counts (Dryad): mammals only, no birds. Note for the clade decision: every organism row in this test is a mammal, so a Mammalia holdout would make the whole test held-out data already seen by its builder","checked":"2026-10-31"}],"power":{"generated_at":"2026-10-31T14:41:43.541Z","question":"Which held-out clade leaves enough species in the public tables for the builders’ own pre-registered minimum sample sizes to be met, so the exam can reach a verdict?","method":"Each completed claim test’s analysis.py was copied to a scratch directory, its class filter (\"Aves\") swapped for the candidate clade, and run with --exam. The builder’s decision rule, including its minimum n, was then applied to the held-out species alone (holdout/exam-results/rules.mjs). The frozen Aves split was not changed.","tests":[{"test":"kimura-heterozygosity","clade":"Aves","class_filter_sites":3,"held_out_n":13,"builder_min_n":50,"clears_minimum":false,"held_out_verdict":"inconclusive","decisive":false,"held_out_measured":{"value":0.06858780076164865,"unit":"OLS slope of log10(pi) on log10(census N) among held-out species only","n":13,"uncertainty":"95% CI [-0.021, 0.158] (normal approximation)","extra":{"spearman_rho_heldout":0.5384615384615384,"heldout_mean_residual_from_training_fit":-0.047751058889177085,"training_fit":{"slope":0.10731485075894677,"ci95":[0.07771085302172728,0.13691884849616626],"n":160}}},"training_n":160,"training_verdict":"refutes","reason":"underpowered: 13 held-out species, the pre-registered rule needs 50"},{"test":"kimura-heterozygosity","clade":"Mammalia","class_filter_sites":3,"held_out_n":40,"builder_min_n":50,"clears_minimum":false,"held_out_verdict":"inconclusive","decisive":false,"held_out_measured":{"value":0.05788948572008206,"unit":"OLS slope of log10(pi) on log10(census N) among held-out species only","n":40,"uncertainty":"95% CI [-0.025, 0.141] (normal approximation)","extra":{"spearman_rho_heldout":0.24878048780487805,"heldout_mean_residual_from_training_fit":-0.45578736339230713,"training_fit":{"slope":0.06325385770151865,"ci95":[0.028702343736651745,0.09780537166638555],"n":133}}},"training_n":133,"training_verdict":"refutes","reason":"underpowered: 40 held-out species, the pre-registered rule needs 50"},{"test":"hamilton-senescence","clade":"Aves","class_filter_sites":1,"held_out_n":8,"builder_min_n":15,"clears_minimum":false,"held_out_verdict":"inconclusive","decisive":false,"held_out_measured":{"value":0.625,"unit":"fraction of held-out species with Spearman rho(age, adult mortality) > 0","n":8,"extra":{"rising":5,"falling":2,"flat":1,"mean_spearman_rho":0.08174827223593134}},"training_n":35,"training_verdict":"mixed","reason":"underpowered: 8 held-out species, the pre-registered rule needs 15"},{"test":"hamilton-senescence","clade":"Mammalia","class_filter_sites":1,"held_out_n":20,"builder_min_n":15,"clears_minimum":true,"held_out_verdict":"mixed","decisive":true,"held_out_measured":{"value":0.75,"unit":"fraction of held-out species with Spearman rho(age, adult mortality) > 0","n":20,"extra":{"rising":15,"falling":5,"flat":0,"mean_spearman_rho":0.38870314227917296}},"training_n":23,"training_verdict":"refutes","reason":"pre-registered thresholds applied to held-out species alone"}],"inventory":{"Aves":{"taxa":88,"roster_species":48,"genome_ready":35,"with_trait_table":48,"trait_sources":{"avonet":25,"amniote":40,"anage":38,"eltontraits":45},"claims_only_in_clade":12,"claims_mixed":13},"Mammalia":{"taxa":105,"roster_species":43,"genome_ready":31,"with_trait_table":40,"trait_sources":{"pantheria":39,"amniote":34,"anage":38,"eltontraits":39},"claims_only_in_clade":25,"claims_mixed":15}},"decisive_exams_by_clade":{"Aves":0,"Mammalia":1},"clade_currently_frozen":"Aves (confirmed 2026-10-31)"},"nanopubs":{"status":"DRAFTS: unsigned, unpublished, awaiting the key owner's decision on signing and the test registry","built":"2026-10-31T22:41:15Z","ontology":"Project Delphi v2.0 (https://w3id.org/delphi/ontology/), templates from project-delphi-ontology commit 6ba5f9a97a4511c909f5dfd755c7993dd68989f3","note":"Provenance points at the live sub-dashboard copy and at the commit-pinned holdout/ tree (da7e271b7015bb60d2d4759c21001895e09852b7). Checked at build time against the local git object: that commit holds the current freeze (2026-10-31T14:38:42.937Z, confirmed), the same exam.json SHA-256 as on disk. The claim-exam and organism-exam records cite the earlier provisional freeze (exam.json 06b797929a27fad5b7173dbaa0c2d9d297deea478a64b7a7935f85caec430360) they ran against, with a node saying the confirmed freeze superseded it and the roster did not move. Before signing: --final with --creator <ORCID> and --commit <sha>, node holdout/nanopubs/check.mjs, lint, then test registry.","lint_exemptions":3,"records":[{"file":"holdout/nanopubs/unsigned/exam-kimura-heterozygosity-aves.trig","kind":"held-out exam of a claim test","introduces":"https://w3id.org/delphi/resource/assessment/holdout-exam-kimura-heterozygosity-aves","verdict":"inconclusive","registry":null,"trustyUri":null,"bytes":13630},{"file":"holdout/nanopubs/unsigned/exam-hamilton-senescence-aves.trig","kind":"held-out exam of a claim test","introduces":"https://w3id.org/delphi/resource/assessment/holdout-exam-hamilton-senescence-aves","verdict":"inconclusive","registry":null,"trustyUri":null,"bytes":13975},{"file":"holdout/nanopubs/unsigned/prereg-organism-design-aves.trig","kind":"pre-registered hypothesis (organism-design exam)","introduces":"https://w3id.org/delphi/resource/hypothesis/organism-design-blueprint-predicts-aves-anatomy","verdict":null,"registry":null,"trustyUri":null,"bytes":5082},{"file":"holdout/nanopubs/unsigned/exam-organism-design-aves.trig","kind":"held-out exam of the organism-design tool","introduces":"https://w3id.org/delphi/resource/assessment/holdout-exam-organism-design-aves","verdict":"inconclusive","registry":null,"trustyUri":null,"bytes":11344},{"file":"holdout/nanopubs/unsigned/clade-analysis.trig","kind":"clade analysis","introduces":"https://w3id.org/delphi/resource/claim/holdout-clade-aves-blind-for-all-current-tests","verdict":null,"registry":null,"trustyUri":null,"bytes":15038},{"file":"holdout/nanopubs/unsigned/leak-check.trig","kind":"leak check","introduces":"https://w3id.org/delphi/resource/claim/holdout-leak-check-clean-2026-10-31","verdict":null,"registry":null,"trustyUri":null,"bytes":11804},{"file":"holdout/nanopubs/unsigned/triage-coverage.trig","kind":"triage coverage","introduces":"https://w3id.org/delphi/resource/claim/holdout-triage-coverage-2026-10-31","verdict":null,"registry":null,"trustyUri":null,"bytes":9090},{"file":"holdout/nanopubs/unsigned/burned-darwin1859-ch01-10.trig","kind":"burned exam item","introduces":"https://w3id.org/delphi/resource/assessment/holdout-exam-eligibility-darwin1859-ch01-10","verdict":"burned","registry":null,"trustyUri":null,"bytes":5036},{"file":"holdout/nanopubs/unsigned/burned-thompson1917-ch15-01.trig","kind":"burned exam item","introduces":"https://w3id.org/delphi/resource/assessment/holdout-exam-eligibility-thompson1917-ch15-01","verdict":"burned","registry":null,"trustyUri":null,"bytes":5010},{"file":"holdout/nanopubs/unsigned/ruling-formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims.trig","kind":"ruling","introduces":"https://w3id.org/delphi/resource/assessment/holdout-ruling-formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims","verdict":"eligible","registry":null,"trustyUri":null,"bytes":14829}]},"rulings":[{"id":"formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims","date":"2026-10-31","asked_by":"hub (session scienceclaw-03), relaying the nanopub curation pass, which flagged lean/nanopubs/unsigned/law-thompson1917-ch02-07.trig as Aves content in a builder's drafts and did not judge it","ruled_by":"holdout thread (session scienceclaw-93)","question":"Does a formal statement (Lean 4 theorem) of a claim whose inventory organisms are birds count as holdout contamination, and did the leak checker see it?","subject":{"claims":[{"id":"thompson1917-ch02-06","side_in_exam":"holdout","label":"Power needed for flight grows as length^3.5 while muscle power grows as length^3","inventory_organisms":"class Aves, Struthio camelus and one more bird key; the claim is Thompson's general scaling argument stated for birds"},{"id":"thompson1917-ch02-07","side_in_exam":"mixed","label":"Ostrich and moa have passed the size at which muscular flight is possible","inventory_organisms":"Struthio camelus and Dinornithiformes (held out); the training-side match is 'a bird as large as a man', which is a hypothetical bird, not a human observation"}],"files":["lean/nanopubs/unsigned/law-thompson1917-ch02-07.trig","lean/nanopubs/unsigned/scope-thompson1917-ch02-07.trig","lean/nanopubs/unsigned/law-thompson1917-ch02-06.trig","lean/Delphi/Scaling.lean","physics/tests/thompson1917-ch02-06/result.json"]},"ruling":"Not a leak. Not burned. Both claims stay eligible for a blind exam on the held-out birds.","reasoning":["Contamination means a bird measurement informed a law before the exam. A theorem of a model contains no measurement: exists_size_limit proves that under the cube law, the area law and the muscle-power premise there is a size above which power required exceeds power available, and supplies no value for it. The record's own scope note says nothing here places the ostrich, the moa or a man-sized bird above that size.","The only bird content in the drafts is Thompson's sentence (claim text that was in the inputs before the freeze) and the words ostrich and moa in the title copied from the claim. No scientific name, identifier, trait row or genome of a held-out taxon appears in any lean file: the widened scan of 2026-10-31 found 0 held-out names under lean/.","The physics thread's claim test of thompson1917-ch02-06 ran on flying fish and other non-bird fliers with class Aves dropped at parse time (physics/SEARCHES.md); the scan finds held-out names under physics/ only in fetched full-text articles, none in an analysis or data file.","Neither artefact can be scored on birds, so neither burns the exam: the theorem predicts no number, and the physics test's fitted quantities were never evaluated on a bird. A later blind exam of the same law on the roster (AVONET mass, wing area and flight status) would be the first contact between the law and bird data.","The rule for builders forbids claim texts that only Aves organisms support as training material. ch02-06 is listed on the holdout side because its inventory organisms are birds, but the law it states is about any flier of fixed proportions; it is Thompson's example that is avian, not the law. The ruling is that the rule applies to data and to organism-specific claims, not to a scaling law tested on non-birds or stated formally."],"checker_before":"default scope was claim-tests/, organism-design/ and swarm/, and the extension list excluded .trig and .lean; lean/nanopubs/unsigned/ was not scanned, and the drafts name the birds only by common name, which no signal matched. The curator's flag was the only detection.","checker_after":"default scope is every top-level folder except holdout/, organisms/, docs/, dashboard/ (its per-thread data copies under dashboard/public/t are scanned), node_modules/, assets/ and .git, with the reason for each exclusion printed; .trig, .ttl, .nt, .nq, .lean, .jsonl and .toml are scanned; a new signal fires on the id of any claim whose inventory organisms are all held out (12 ids), and warns on the 13 mixed ones. Both ch02-07 drafts now trip the claim-id signal and are tolerated under a lean/ allowlist entry that cites this ruling.","does_not_establish":["That the theorem is a faithful rendering of Thompson's argument (the lean thread's own faithfulness assessment is 'not assessed').","Anything about the ostrich or the moa.","That no builder read bird data outside this tree."],"to_the_builders":["lean thread: the record's label 'Ostrich and moa have passed the size at which muscular flight is possible (Lean 4, kernel-checked)' names the bird claim as the thing kernel-checked, while the assertion proves only that a size limit exists; a reader who stops at the label will take the bird claim as proved. Label the theorem, not the claim.","lean thread: the rdfs:comment lists Kimura, Fisher and Maynard Smith assumptions on a scaling record, and the evidence item reports '0 deliberately broken variants' as mutation evidence, which is no evidence; both read as copied boilerplate.","physics thread: the same two claim ids are tolerated under physics/ for the reason above; a future test that reads a bird row would still be a leak."]}],"allowlist":[{"path":"claim-tests/math-bio-theorems/kimura-heterozygosity/data/combined_data.tsv","kind":"file","taxa":null,"claims":null,"pattern":null,"committed_before":null,"reason":"downloaded source table (Buffalo 2021) that happens to contain bird rows; analysis.py drops class Aves before fitting (lines 44-45) and marks them held_out in the derived table"},{"path":"claim-tests/math-bio-theorems/kimura-heterozygosity/derived/species_table.csv","kind":"file","taxa":null,"claims":null,"pattern":null,"committed_before":null,"reason":"derived table written by analysis.py with a held_out column; bird rows are labelled, not fitted"},{"path":"swarm/compare/","kind":"prefix","taxa":["Columba livia","columba-livia","Columbidae"],"claims":["darwin1859-ch01-10","darwin1859-ch07-04"],"pattern":null,"committed_before":null,"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason."},{"path":"organism-design/exam/","kind":"prefix","taxa":null,"claims":null,"pattern":null,"committed_before":null,"reason":"the organism thread's exam predictions for the roster, emitted from exam.json identifiers only; scoring rule pre-registered in holdout/exam-results/organism-design/PREREG.md before the file existed"},{"path":"claim-tests/thompson-growth-form/thompson1917-ch04-13/data/ccdb_statistics_Angiosperms.csv","kind":"file","taxa":["Troglodytes"],"claims":null,"pattern":null,"committed_before":null,"reason":"homonym: Troglodytes here is an angiosperm genus in the Chromosome Counts Database, not the wren genus; the file holds plant chromosome counts only"},{"path":"swarm/compare/verify-cache.json","kind":"file","taxa":["Troglodytes"],"claims":null,"pattern":null,"committed_before":null,"reason":"homonym: the word troglodytes (cave-dwellers) in a fetched article about European cave spiders that a swarm worker proposed as a source; not the wren genus"},{"path":"swarm/PREREG.md","kind":"file","taxa":null,"claims":["darwin1859-ch01-10","darwin1859-ch07-04"],"pattern":null,"committed_before":null,"reason":"the swarm pre-registration names the bird claims it skipped (ch07-04) and the one it had already started (ch01-10, burned); naming an id is how it says so"},{"path":"darwin-origin/","kind":"prefix","taxa":null,"claims":null,"pattern":null,"committed_before":"2026-10-31T05:52:44.982Z","reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry."},{"path":"thompson-growth-form/","kind":"prefix","taxa":null,"claims":null,"pattern":null,"committed_before":"2026-10-31T05:52:44.982Z","reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On Growth and Form, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; same reasoning as darwin-origin/. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry."},{"path":"truth/","kind":"prefix","taxa":null,"claims":null,"pattern":null,"committed_before":"2026-10-31T05:52:44.982Z","reason":"truth-scoring batches of the extracted claims, first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the bird claims are quoted, not built on."},{"path":"physics/prior-art/raw/","kind":"prefix","taxa":null,"claims":null,"pattern":null,"committed_before":null,"reason":"full texts and search responses fetched from PMC, Europe PMC and Crossref for bat, insect and flying-fish flight prior art; the articles carry bird comparison tables. The physics thread states in physics/SEARCHES.md that bird rows of the one compiled table were dropped at parse time and no bird value was read into any file, and this scan finds no held-out name in any physics file outside raw/. Fetched articles are literature the thread read, not data it fitted."},{"path":"physics/","kind":"prefix","taxa":null,"claims":["thompson1917-ch02-06","thompson1917-ch02-07"],"pattern":null,"committed_before":null,"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): the physics thread tested Thompson's flight-scaling law, a claim whose inventory organisms are birds, on flying fish and other non-bird fliers with class Aves excluded (physics/tests/thompson1917-ch02-06/result.json, verdict inconclusive). The law is about any flier; the test used no bird row; the held-out birds remain available for a blind exam of the same law."},{"path":"lean/","kind":"prefix","taxa":null,"claims":["thompson1917-ch02-06","thompson1917-ch02-07"],"pattern":null,"committed_before":null,"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): Lean 4 statements of Thompson's flight-scaling law and its corollary (lean/Delphi/Scaling.lean). A theorem of a model carries no measurement; the records' own scope notes say nothing about the ostrich or the moa is established; the birds appear only in the claim's title. A formal statement cannot be fitted to held-out data and cannot be scored on it either, so it neither contaminates nor burns the exam."},{"path":"dashboard/public/t/physics/","kind":"prefix","taxa":null,"claims":["thompson1917-ch02-06","thompson1917-ch02-07"],"pattern":null,"committed_before":null,"reason":"published copy of the physics thread's data; same ruling as physics/"},{"path":"dashboard/public/t/lean/","kind":"prefix","taxa":null,"claims":["thompson1917-ch02-06","thompson1917-ch02-07"],"pattern":null,"committed_before":null,"reason":"published copy of the lean thread's data; same ruling as lean/"},{"path":"crosscheck-frontier/","kind":"prefix","taxa":null,"claims":["thompson1917-ch02-06","thompson1917-ch02-07"],"pattern":null,"committed_before":null,"reason":"the hub's cross-check of the frontier models queried the flight-scaling claim by id and logged the call; no organism data"},{"path":"nanopubs-index/","kind":"prefix","taxa":null,"claims":null,"pattern":null,"committed_before":null,"reason":"the curator's index of every unsigned draft in the tree quotes each record's head, including the holdout's own burned record (Columba livia) and the pre-freeze claim records; it is an index of records, not a builder"},{"path":"validation/","kind":"prefix","taxa":["Columba livia","columba-livia"],"claims":["darwin1859-ch01-04"],"pattern":null,"committed_before":null,"reason":"MCP server conformance test (validation/MCP-TEST-REPORT.md): the harness calls delphi_get_organism with the inventory id columba-livia and checks claim pages by id, and records the answers; it tests the server, builds no law, and Columba livia is the organism of the burned claim darwin1859-ch01-10"},{"path":"dashboard/public/t/validation/","kind":"prefix","taxa":["Columba livia","columba-livia"],"claims":["darwin1859-ch01-04"],"pattern":null,"committed_before":null,"reason":"published copy of the MCP test report; same reasoning as validation/"},{"path":"genotype/causal-chains.json","kind":"file","taxa":["Gallus gallus"],"claims":null,"pattern":"Ng 2002","committed_before":null,"reason":"the organism field of a cited experiment (Ng 2002: zebrafish and chick) on one gene-to-phenotype link for the fin genes; a literature citation naming the chick as one of two experimental organisms, no bird trait value. Disclosed to the genotype thread."},{"path":"dashboard/public/t/genotype/data.json","kind":"file","taxa":["Gallus gallus"],"claims":null,"pattern":"Ng 2002","committed_before":null,"reason":"published copy of genotype/causal-chains.json; same reasoning"},{"path":"simulation-readiness/readiness.json","kind":"file","taxa":["Struthio camelus"],"claims":null,"pattern":"Ostrich Struthio camelus","committed_before":null,"reason":"an organism tally of the rows a parameter-database query returned (one of twenty rows for the Danio rerio query is labelled ostrich); the thread's README states no bird data was fetched or used, and the tally counts a search hit it did not read"},{"path":"dashboard/public/t/organism/data/aves-predictions.json","kind":"file","taxa":null,"claims":null,"pattern":null,"committed_before":null,"reason":"published copy of organism-design/exam/aves-predictions.json, the organism thread's blind exam predictions for the roster (see the organism-design/exam/ entry)"},{"path":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/","kind":"prefix","taxa":["Columba livia","columba-livia","Columbidae"],"claims":["darwin1859-ch01-10","darwin1859-ch07-04"],"pattern":null,"committed_before":null,"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry"},{"path":"organism-design/nanopubs/UPSTREAM-ASK.md","kind":"file","taxa":null,"claims":["darwin1859-ch01-10"],"pattern":null,"committed_before":null,"reason":"refers to the holdout's own burned record for that claim by file name"},{"path":"decisions/ideas.json","kind":"file","taxa":null,"claims":["thompson1917-ch02-06"],"pattern":null,"committed_before":null,"reason":"the decisions log records the idea to exclude birds from the flight-envelope comparison because thompson1917-ch02-06 is listed on the holdout side; it names the id to say the clade was kept out"}],"leaks":{"scanned_at":"2026-10-31T22:44:33.020Z","files":[],"targets":["anatomy-model","claim-tests","conditions","crosscheck-frontier","darwin-origin","decisions","design-validation","development","genotype","lean","math-bio-theorems","mcp","md","nanopubs-index","open-problems","organism-design","physics","physiology","research","sequences","sim-engine","simulation-readiness","structures","swarm","thompson-growth-form","truth","validation","wolfram-nks","dashboard/public/t"],"excluded":{"holdout":"the exam itself: roster, rules, results and these records","organisms":"the inventory the split is computed from; it names every taxon by construction","docs":"docs/claims.json is an input to make-split.mjs and the claim pages are built from it","dashboard":"site code and build output; the per-thread data copies under dashboard/public/t are scanned","node_modules":"dependencies","assets":"static site assets",".git":"history"},"signals":{"held_out_taxa":88,"holdout_claim_ids":12,"mixed_claim_ids":13},"clade":"Aves","warns":112195,"allowed":107124,"allowed_files":[{"file":"organism-design/exam/aves-predictions.json","n":52628,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["NCBI taxid 8839","Anas platyrhynchos","GBIF key 9761484","NCBI taxid 8843","Anser anser","GBIF key 2498036"],"reason":"the organism thread's exam predictions for the roster, emitted from exam.json identifiers only; scoring rule pre-registered in holdout/exam-results/organism-design/PREREG.md before the file existed","what_distinct":150},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/organism/data/aves-predictions.json","n":52628,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["NCBI taxid 8839","Anas platyrhynchos","GBIF key 9761484","NCBI taxid 8843","Anser anser","GBIF key 2498036"],"reason":"published copy of organism-design/exam/aves-predictions.json, the organism thread's blind exam predictions for the roster (see the organism-design/exam/ entry)","what_distinct":150},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/lean/lean.json","n":191,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"published copy of the lean thread's data; same ruling as lean/","what_distinct":1},{"file":"lean/eliminate/ledger.open-problems.json","n":88,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): Lean 4 statements of Thompson's flight-scaling law and its corollary (lean/Delphi/Scaling.lean). A theorem of a model carries no measurement; the records' own scope notes say nothing about the ostrich or the moa is established; the birds appear only in the claim's title. A formal statement cannot be fitted to held-out data and cannot be scored on it either, so it neither contaminates nor burns the exam.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"validation/mcp-test-results.json","n":47,"kinds":["taxon","claim"],"what":["slug columba-livia","Columba livia","GBIF key 2495414","claim darwin1859-ch01-04"],"reason":"MCP server conformance test (validation/MCP-TEST-REPORT.md): the harness calls delphi_get_organism with the inventory id columba-livia and checks claim pages by id, and records the answers; it tests the server, builds no law, and Columba livia is the organism of the burned claim darwin1859-ch01-10","what_distinct":4},{"file":"lean/eliminate/ledger.json","n":36,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): Lean 4 statements of Thompson's flight-scaling law and its corollary (lean/Delphi/Scaling.lean). A theorem of a model carries no measurement; the records' own scope notes say nothing about the ostrich or the moa is established; the birds appear only in the claim's title. A formal statement cannot be fitted to held-out data and cannot be scored on it either, so it neither contaminates nor burns the exam.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/assessments-unsigned/darwin1859-ch01-10--gpt.trig","n":30,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia","Columbidae"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":3},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/assessments-unsigned/darwin1859-ch01-10--grok.trig","n":30,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/assessments-unsigned/darwin1859-ch01-04--grok.trig","n":29,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-04"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/assessments-unsigned/darwin1859-ch04-07--grok.trig","n":29,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch04-07"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/assessments-unsigned/darwin1859-ch05-03--gpt.trig","n":29,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch05-03"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/assessments-unsigned/darwin1859-ch05-03--grok.trig","n":29,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch05-03"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/assessments-unsigned/darwin1859-ch07-04--grok.trig","n":29,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch07-04"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/assessments-unsigned/darwin1859-ch07-05--grok.trig","n":29,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch07-05"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/assessments-unsigned/darwin1859-ch12-12--gpt.trig","n":29,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch12-12"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/assessments-unsigned/darwin1859-ch12-12--grok.trig","n":29,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch12-12"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/assessments-unsigned/darwin1859-ch13-12--gpt.trig","n":29,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch13-12"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/assessments-unsigned/darwin1859-ch13-12--grok.trig","n":29,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch13-12"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/assessments-unsigned/darwin1859-ch13-25--gpt.trig","n":29,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch13-25"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/assessments-unsigned/darwin1859-ch13-25--grok.trig","n":29,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch13-25"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"validation/mcp-test/results-main.json","n":29,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["slug columba-livia","Columba livia","GBIF key 2495414"],"reason":"MCP server conformance test (validation/MCP-TEST-REPORT.md): the harness calls delphi_get_organism with the inventory id columba-livia and checks claim pages by id, and records the answers; it tests the server, builds no law, and Columba livia is the organism of the burned claim darwin1859-ch01-10","what_distinct":3},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/assessments-unsigned/darwin1859-ch01-04--gpt.trig","n":28,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-04"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/assessments-unsigned/darwin1859-ch04-07--gpt.trig","n":28,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch04-07"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/assessments-unsigned/darwin1859-ch07-04--gpt.trig","n":28,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch07-04"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/assessments-unsigned/darwin1859-ch07-05--gpt.trig","n":28,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch07-05"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/assessments-unsigned/darwin1859-ch07-07--gpt.trig","n":28,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch07-07"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/assessments-unsigned/darwin1859-ch07-07--grok.trig","n":28,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch07-07"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/assessments-unsigned/darwin1859-ch08-09--gpt.trig","n":28,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch08-09"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"thompson-growth-form/nanopubs/assessments-unsigned/thompson1917-ch02-06--gpt.trig","n":28,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On Growth and Form, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; same reasoning as darwin-origin/. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/assessments-unsigned/darwin1859-ch08-09--grok.trig","n":27,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch08-09"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"thompson-growth-form/nanopubs/assessments-unsigned/thompson1917-ch02-06--grok.trig","n":27,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On Growth and Form, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; same reasoning as darwin-origin/. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"thompson-growth-form/nanopubs/assessments-signed/thompson1917-ch02-06--gpt.trig","n":23,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On Growth and Form, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; same reasoning as darwin-origin/. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/manifest.jsonl","n":22,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-04","claim darwin1859-ch01-10","claim darwin1859-ch04-07","claim darwin1859-ch05-03","claim darwin1859-ch07-04","claim darwin1859-ch07-05"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":11},{"file":"thompson-growth-form/nanopubs/assessments-signed/thompson1917-ch02-06--grok.trig","n":22,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On Growth and Form, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; same reasoning as darwin-origin/. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"lean/eliminate/ledger.genotype.json","n":20,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): Lean 4 statements of Thompson's flight-scaling law and its corollary (lean/Delphi/Scaling.lean). A theorem of a model carries no measurement; the records' own scope notes say nothing about the ostrich or the moa is established; the birds appear only in the claim's title. A formal statement cannot be fitted to held-out data and cannot be scored on it either, so it neither contaminates nor burns the exam.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"nanopubs-index/index.json","n":20,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-04","claim darwin1859-ch01-10","claim darwin1859-ch04-07","claim darwin1859-ch05-03","claim darwin1859-ch07-04","claim darwin1859-ch07-05"],"reason":"the curator's index of every unsigned draft in the tree quotes each record's head, including the holdout's own burned record (Columba livia) and the pre-freeze claim records; it is an index of records, not a builder","what_distinct":13},{"file":"swarm/compare/verify-cache.json","n":19,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Columba livia","NCBI taxid 8932","Columbidae","Troglodytes"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":4},{"file":"lean/eliminate/ledger.empirical.json","n":18,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): Lean 4 statements of Thompson's flight-scaling law and its corollary (lean/Delphi/Scaling.lean). A theorem of a model carries no measurement; the records' own scope notes say nothing about the ostrich or the moa is established; the birds appear only in the claim's title. A formal statement cannot be fitted to held-out data and cannot be scored on it either, so it neither contaminates nor burns the exam.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"validation/mcp-test/results-worktree.json","n":18,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-04","slug columba-livia","Columba livia","GBIF key 2495414"],"reason":"MCP server conformance test (validation/MCP-TEST-REPORT.md): the harness calls delphi_get_organism with the inventory id columba-livia and checks claim pages by id, and records the answers; it tests the server, builds no law, and Columba livia is the organism of the burned claim darwin1859-ch01-10","what_distinct":4},{"file":"claim-tests/math-bio-theorems/kimura-heterozygosity/data/combined_data.tsv","n":15,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Anas platyrhynchos","Anatidae","Spheniscidae","Accipitridae","Accipitriformes","Aquila"],"reason":"downloaded source table (Buffalo 2021) that happens to contain bird rows; analysis.py drops class Aves before fitting (lines 44-45) and marks them held_out in the derived table","what_distinct":11},{"file":"darwin-origin/claims.json","n":13,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-04","claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia","claim darwin1859-ch04-07","claim darwin1859-ch05-03","claim darwin1859-ch07-04"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":12},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/isolated-2026-10-31T06-08-36-rep1/calls/010-darwin1859-ch01-10-w1.json","n":12,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia","slug columba-livia","NCBI taxid 8932"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":4},{"file":"darwin-origin/worklist.tsv","n":11,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-04","claim darwin1859-ch01-10","claim darwin1859-ch04-07","claim darwin1859-ch05-03","claim darwin1859-ch07-04","claim darwin1859-ch07-05"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":11},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/single-2026-10-31T06-15-20-rep1/calls/001-single-all.json","n":11,"kinds":["taxon","claim"],"what":["Columba livia","slug columba-livia","NCBI taxid 8932","claim darwin1859-ch01-10"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":4},{"file":"validation/MCP-TEST-REPORT.md","n":11,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Columba livia","slug columba-livia","GBIF key 2495414"],"reason":"MCP server conformance test (validation/MCP-TEST-REPORT.md): the harness calls delphi_get_organism with the inventory id columba-livia and checks claim pages by id, and records the answers; it tests the server, builds no law, and Columba livia is the organism of the burned claim darwin1859-ch01-10","what_distinct":3},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/validation/MCP-TEST-REPORT.md","n":11,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Columba livia","slug columba-livia","GBIF key 2495414"],"reason":"published copy of the MCP test report; same reasoning as validation/","what_distinct":3},{"file":"darwin-origin/inputs/pg1228.txt","n":10,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Columba livia","Apteryx","Parus major","Troglodytes","Rhea"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":5},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/decentralized-2026-10-31T06-13-25-rep1/calls/010-darwin1859-ch01-10-q-evolution-a1.json","n":10,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia","slug columba-livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":3},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/isolated-2026-10-31T05-57-46/calls/010-darwin1859-ch01-10-w1.json","n":9,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia","slug columba-livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":3},{"file":"swarm/compare/results.json","n":8,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/centralized-2026-10-31T05-59-47/calls/011-darwin1859-ch01-10-q-evolution-a1.json","n":8,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia","slug columba-livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":3},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/decentralized-2026-10-31T06-02-31/calls/009-darwin1859-ch01-10-q-evolution-a1.json","n":8,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia","slug columba-livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":3},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/results.json","n":8,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry","what_distinct":2},{"file":"physics/prior-art/raw/pmc-C-rousettus-muscles.txt","n":7,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Turdus","Turdus merula","Gallus gallus","Perdix perdix","Falco","Accipitriformes"],"reason":"full texts and search responses fetched from PMC, Europe PMC and Crossref for bat, insect and flying-fish flight prior art; the articles carry bird comparison tables. The physics thread states in physics/SEARCHES.md that bird rows of the one compiled table were dropped at parse time and no bird value was read into any file, and this scan finds no held-out name in any physics file outside raw/. Fetched articles are literature the thread read, not data it fitted.","what_distinct":6},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/decentralized-2026-10-31T06-02-31/calls/019-darwin1859-ch01-10-q-holdout-a2.json","n":7,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/isolated-2026-10-31T06-08-36-rep1/plans/darwin1859-ch01-10.a1.json","n":7,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia","NCBI taxid 8932","slug columba-livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":4},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/single-2026-10-31T06-05-08/calls/001-single-all.json","n":7,"kinds":["taxon","claim"],"what":["Columba livia","slug columba-livia","claim darwin1859-ch01-10"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":3},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/single-2026-10-31T06-15-20-rep1/plans/darwin1859-ch01-10.a1.json","n":7,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia","slug columba-livia","NCBI taxid 8932"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":4},{"file":"lean/eliminate/ledger.flier.json","n":6,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): Lean 4 statements of Thompson's flight-scaling law and its corollary (lean/Delphi/Scaling.lean). A theorem of a model carries no measurement; the records' own scope notes say nothing about the ostrich or the moa is established; the birds appear only in the claim's title. A formal statement cannot be fitted to held-out data and cannot be scored on it either, so it neither contaminates nor burns the exam.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"lean/eliminate/ledger.physiology.json","n":6,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): Lean 4 statements of Thompson's flight-scaling law and its corollary (lean/Delphi/Scaling.lean). A theorem of a model carries no measurement; the records' own scope notes say nothing about the ostrich or the moa is established; the birds appear only in the claim's title. A formal statement cannot be fitted to held-out data and cannot be scored on it either, so it neither contaminates nor burns the exam.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"lean/eliminate/ledger.tff.json","n":6,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): Lean 4 statements of Thompson's flight-scaling law and its corollary (lean/Delphi/Scaling.lean). A theorem of a model carries no measurement; the records' own scope notes say nothing about the ostrich or the moa is established; the birds appear only in the claim's title. A formal statement cannot be fitted to held-out data and cannot be scored on it either, so it neither contaminates nor burns the exam.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"lean/nanopubs/manifest.json","n":6,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): Lean 4 statements of Thompson's flight-scaling law and its corollary (lean/Delphi/Scaling.lean). A theorem of a model carries no measurement; the records' own scope notes say nothing about the ostrich or the moa is established; the birds appear only in the claim's title. A formal statement cannot be fitted to held-out data and cannot be scored on it either, so it neither contaminates nor burns the exam.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"lean/nanopubs/unsigned/law-thompson1917-ch02-06.trig","n":6,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): Lean 4 statements of Thompson's flight-scaling law and its corollary (lean/Delphi/Scaling.lean). A theorem of a model carries no measurement; the records' own scope notes say nothing about the ostrich or the moa is established; the birds appear only in the claim's title. A formal statement cannot be fitted to held-out data and cannot be scored on it either, so it neither contaminates nor burns the exam.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/centralized-2026-10-31T06-10-21-rep1/calls/018-darwin1859-ch01-10-q-evolution-a1.json","n":6,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/decentralized-2026-10-31T06-13-25-rep1/plans/darwin1859-ch01-10.a1.json","n":6,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia","slug columba-livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":3},{"file":"physics/nanopubs/build.py","n":5,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): the physics thread tested Thompson's flight-scaling law, a claim whose inventory organisms are birds, on flying fish and other non-bird fliers with class Aves excluded (physics/tests/thompson1917-ch02-06/result.json, verdict inconclusive). The law is about any flier; the test used no bird row; the held-out birds remain available for a blind exam of the same law.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/decentralized-2026-10-31T06-02-31/log.jsonl","n":5,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/isolated-2026-10-31T05-57-46/plans/darwin1859-ch01-10.a1.json","n":5,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia","slug columba-livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":3},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/runs/decentralized/log.jsonl","n":5,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry","what_distinct":2},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/runs/isolated/plans/darwin1859-ch01-10.a1.json","n":5,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia","slug columba-livia"],"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry","what_distinct":3},{"file":"claim-tests/math-bio-theorems/kimura-heterozygosity/derived/species_table.csv","n":4,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Meleagris gallopavo","Troglodytes","Aquila","Gallus gallus"],"reason":"derived table written by analysis.py with a held_out column; bird rows are labelled, not fitted","what_distinct":4},{"file":"darwin-origin/assessment/inputs/batch-1.json","n":4,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-04","claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":3},{"file":"darwin-origin/assessment/inputs/batch-3.json","n":4,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch07-04","claim darwin1859-ch07-05","claim darwin1859-ch07-07","claim darwin1859-ch08-09"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":4},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/signed/darwin1859-ch01-10.trig","n":4,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/unsigned/darwin1859-ch01-10.trig","n":4,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"physics/prior-art/raw/pmc-C-bat-flapping-power.txt","n":4,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Columba livia","Numida meleagris"],"reason":"full texts and search responses fetched from PMC, Europe PMC and Crossref for bat, insect and flying-fish flight prior art; the articles carry bird comparison tables. The physics thread states in physics/SEARCHES.md that bird rows of the one compiled table were dropped at parse time and no bird value was read into any file, and this scan finds no held-out name in any physics file outside raw/. Fetched articles are literature the thread read, not data it fitted.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"swarm/compare/claims.json","n":4,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md","n":4,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/centralized-2026-10-31T05-59-47/plans/darwin1859-ch01-10.a1.json","n":4,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia","slug columba-livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":3},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/decentralized-2026-10-31T06-02-31/board.json","n":4,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/decentralized-2026-10-31T06-02-31/plans/darwin1859-ch01-10.a1.json","n":4,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia","slug columba-livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":3},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/decentralized-2026-10-31T06-02-31/plans/darwin1859-ch01-10.a2.json","n":4,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/single-2026-10-31T06-05-08/plans/darwin1859-ch01-10.a1.json","n":4,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia","slug columba-livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":3},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/single-2026-10-31T06-15-20-rep1/summary.json","n":4,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia","NCBI taxid 8932"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":3},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/single-2026-10-31T06-15-20-rep1/verify/darwin1859-ch01-10.a1.json","n":4,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["NCBI taxid 8932"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"thompson-growth-form/nanopubs/manifest.jsonl","n":4,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On Growth and Form, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; same reasoning as darwin-origin/. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/claims.json","n":4,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry","what_distinct":2},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/DEVIATIONS.md","n":4,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry","what_distinct":2},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/runs/centralized/plans/darwin1859-ch01-10.a1.json","n":4,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia","slug columba-livia"],"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry","what_distinct":3},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/runs/decentralized/board.json","n":4,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry","what_distinct":2},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/runs/decentralized/plans/darwin1859-ch01-10.a1.json","n":4,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia","slug columba-livia"],"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry","what_distinct":3},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/runs/decentralized/plans/darwin1859-ch01-10.a2.json","n":4,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry","what_distinct":2},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/runs/single/plans/darwin1859-ch01-10.a1.json","n":4,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia","slug columba-livia"],"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry","what_distinct":3},{"file":"crosscheck-frontier/calls.json","n":3,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"the hub's cross-check of the frontier models queried the flight-scaling claim by id and logged the call; no organism data","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/assessment/inputs/batch-5.json","n":3,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch12-12","claim darwin1859-ch13-12","claim darwin1859-ch13-25"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":3},{"file":"decisions/ideas.json","n":3,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"the decisions log records the idea to exclude birds from the flight-envelope comparison because thompson1917-ch02-06 is listed on the holdout side; it names the id to say the clade was kept out","what_distinct":1},{"file":"lean/mutate.mjs","n":3,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): Lean 4 statements of Thompson's flight-scaling law and its corollary (lean/Delphi/Scaling.lean). A theorem of a model carries no measurement; the records' own scope notes say nothing about the ostrich or the moa is established; the birds appear only in the claim's title. A formal statement cannot be fitted to held-out data and cannot be scored on it either, so it neither contaminates nor burns the exam.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"lean/mutations.json","n":3,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): Lean 4 statements of Thompson's flight-scaling law and its corollary (lean/Delphi/Scaling.lean). A theorem of a model carries no measurement; the records' own scope notes say nothing about the ostrich or the moa is established; the birds appear only in the claim's title. A formal statement cannot be fitted to held-out data and cannot be scored on it either, so it neither contaminates nor burns the exam.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"lean/nanopubs/build.mjs","n":3,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): Lean 4 statements of Thompson's flight-scaling law and its corollary (lean/Delphi/Scaling.lean). A theorem of a model carries no measurement; the records' own scope notes say nothing about the ostrich or the moa is established; the birds appear only in the claim's title. A formal statement cannot be fitted to held-out data and cannot be scored on it either, so it neither contaminates nor burns the exam.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"lean/report.mjs","n":3,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): Lean 4 statements of Thompson's flight-scaling law and its corollary (lean/Delphi/Scaling.lean). A theorem of a model carries no measurement; the records' own scope notes say nothing about the ostrich or the moa is established; the birds appear only in the claim's title. A formal statement cannot be fitted to held-out data and cannot be scored on it either, so it neither contaminates nor burns the exam.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"nanopubs-index/catalogue.md","n":3,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06","claim darwin1859-ch01-10"],"reason":"the curator's index of every unsigned draft in the tree quotes each record's head, including the holdout's own burned record (Columba livia) and the pre-freeze claim records; it is an index of records, not a builder","what_distinct":2},{"file":"physics/analysis.py","n":3,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): the physics thread tested Thompson's flight-scaling law, a claim whose inventory organisms are birds, on flying fish and other non-bird fliers with class Aves excluded (physics/tests/thompson1917-ch02-06/result.json, verdict inconclusive). The law is about any flier; the test used no bird row; the held-out birds remain available for a blind exam of the same law.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"physics/nanopubs/unsigned/evidence-flying-fish-inside-envelope.trig","n":3,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): the physics thread tested Thompson's flight-scaling law, a claim whose inventory organisms are birds, on flying fish and other non-bird fliers with class Aves excluded (physics/tests/thompson1917-ch02-06/result.json, verdict inconclusive). The law is about any flier; the test used no bird row; the held-out birds remain available for a blind exam of the same law.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"physics/nanopubs/unsigned/evidence-speed-vs-wing-loading-inconclusive.trig","n":3,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): the physics thread tested Thompson's flight-scaling law, a claim whose inventory organisms are birds, on flying fish and other non-bird fliers with class Aves excluded (physics/tests/thompson1917-ch02-06/result.json, verdict inconclusive). The law is about any flier; the test used no bird row; the held-out birds remain available for a blind exam of the same law.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"physics/nanopubs/unsigned/evidence-test4-real-fish-powered-flight.trig","n":3,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): the physics thread tested Thompson's flight-scaling law, a claim whose inventory organisms are birds, on flying fish and other non-bird fliers with class Aves excluded (physics/tests/thompson1917-ch02-06/result.json, verdict inconclusive). The law is about any flier; the test used no bird row; the held-out birds remain available for a blind exam of the same law.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"physics/nanopubs/unsigned/finding-sim-v2-launch-not-reachable.trig","n":3,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): the physics thread tested Thompson's flight-scaling law, a claim whose inventory organisms are birds, on flying fish and other non-bird fliers with class Aves excluded (physics/tests/thompson1917-ch02-06/result.json, verdict inconclusive). The law is about any flier; the test used no bird row; the held-out birds remain available for a blind exam of the same law.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"physics/nanopubs/unsigned/finding-sim-v3-drag-not-power.trig","n":3,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): the physics thread tested Thompson's flight-scaling law, a claim whose inventory organisms are birds, on flying fish and other non-bird fliers with class Aves excluded (physics/tests/thompson1917-ch02-06/result.json, verdict inconclusive). The law is about any flier; the test used no bird row; the held-out birds remain available for a blind exam of the same law.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"physics/nanopubs/unsigned/finding-simulator-taxi-glide-sequence-posthoc.trig","n":3,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): the physics thread tested Thompson's flight-scaling law, a claim whose inventory organisms are birds, on flying fish and other non-bird fliers with class Aves excluded (physics/tests/thompson1917-ch02-06/result.json, verdict inconclusive). The law is about any flier; the test used no bird row; the held-out birds remain available for a blind exam of the same law.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"physics/prior-art/raw/pmc-C-pterosaur-hatchling.txt","n":3,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Galliformes","Trochilidae"],"reason":"full texts and search responses fetched from PMC, Europe PMC and Crossref for bat, insect and flying-fish flight prior art; the articles carry bird comparison tables. The physics thread states in physics/SEARCHES.md that bird rows of the one compiled table were dropped at parse time and no bird value was read into any file, and this scan finds no held-out name in any physics file outside raw/. Fetched articles are literature the thread read, not data it fitted.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/centralized-2026-10-31T06-10-21-rep1/plans/darwin1859-ch01-10.a1.json","n":3,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/decentralized-2026-10-31T06-13-25-rep1/board.json","n":3,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/decentralized-2026-10-31T06-13-25-rep1/log.jsonl","n":3,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/isolated-2026-10-31T06-08-36-rep1/log.jsonl","n":3,"kinds":["taxon","claim"],"what":["Columba livia","NCBI taxid 8932","claim darwin1859-ch01-10"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":3},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/isolated-2026-10-31T06-08-36-rep1/summary.json","n":3,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia","NCBI taxid 8932"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":3},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/single-2026-10-31T06-15-20-rep1/log.jsonl","n":3,"kinds":["taxon","claim"],"what":["Columba livia","NCBI taxid 8932","claim darwin1859-ch01-10"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":3},{"file":"thompson-growth-form/assessment/assessments.json","n":3,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06","Apteryx"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On Growth and Form, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; same reasoning as darwin-origin/. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"thompson-growth-form/claims.json","n":3,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06","Apteryx","Gallus gallus"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On Growth and Form, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; same reasoning as darwin-origin/. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":3},{"file":"validation/mcp-test/run.mjs","n":3,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["slug columba-livia","GBIF key 2495414","Columba livia"],"reason":"MCP server conformance test (validation/MCP-TEST-REPORT.md): the harness calls delphi_get_organism with the inventory id columba-livia and checks claim pages by id, and records the answers; it tests the server, builds no law, and Columba livia is the organism of the burned claim darwin1859-ch01-10","what_distinct":3},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/physics/data/nanopubs/evidence-flying-fish-inside-envelope.trig","n":3,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"published copy of the physics thread's data; same ruling as physics/","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/physics/data/nanopubs/evidence-speed-vs-wing-loading-inconclusive.trig","n":3,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"published copy of the physics thread's data; same ruling as physics/","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/physics/data/nanopubs/evidence-test4-real-fish-powered-flight.trig","n":3,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"published copy of the physics thread's data; same ruling as physics/","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/physics/data/nanopubs/finding-sim-v2-launch-not-reachable.trig","n":3,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"published copy of the physics thread's data; same ruling as physics/","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/physics/data/nanopubs/finding-sim-v3-drag-not-power.trig","n":3,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"published copy of the physics thread's data; same ruling as physics/","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/physics/data/nanopubs/finding-simulator-taxi-glide-sequence-posthoc.trig","n":3,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"published copy of the physics thread's data; same ruling as physics/","what_distinct":1},{"file":"crosscheck-frontier/crosscheck.json","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"the hub's cross-check of the frontier models queried the flight-scaling claim by id and logged the call; no organism data","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/assessment/inputs/batch-2.json","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch04-07","claim darwin1859-ch05-03"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"darwin-origin/extraction/A-intro-ch01-02.json","n":2,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Columba livia"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/signed/darwin1859-ch01-04.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-04"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/signed/darwin1859-ch04-07.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch04-07"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/signed/darwin1859-ch05-03.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch05-03"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/signed/darwin1859-ch07-04.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch07-04"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/signed/darwin1859-ch07-05.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch07-05"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/signed/darwin1859-ch07-07.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch07-07"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/signed/darwin1859-ch08-09.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch08-09"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/signed/darwin1859-ch12-12.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch12-12"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/signed/darwin1859-ch13-12.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch13-12"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/signed/darwin1859-ch13-25.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch13-25"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/unsigned/darwin1859-ch01-04.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-04"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/unsigned/darwin1859-ch04-07.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch04-07"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/unsigned/darwin1859-ch05-03.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch05-03"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/unsigned/darwin1859-ch07-04.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch07-04"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/unsigned/darwin1859-ch07-05.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch07-05"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/unsigned/darwin1859-ch07-07.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch07-07"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/unsigned/darwin1859-ch08-09.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch08-09"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/unsigned/darwin1859-ch12-12.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch12-12"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/unsigned/darwin1859-ch13-12.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch13-12"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"darwin-origin/nanopubs/unsigned/darwin1859-ch13-25.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch13-25"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On the Origin of Species, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the book names birds and so do the claims. These are the inputs the split is computed from (docs/claims.json is built from them), not a law built on bird data. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"lean/constraints.json","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): Lean 4 statements of Thompson's flight-scaling law and its corollary (lean/Delphi/Scaling.lean). A theorem of a model carries no measurement; the records' own scope notes say nothing about the ostrich or the moa is established; the birds appear only in the claim's title. A formal statement cannot be fitted to held-out data and cannot be scored on it either, so it neither contaminates nor burns the exam.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"lean/eliminate/build-constraints.mjs","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): Lean 4 statements of Thompson's flight-scaling law and its corollary (lean/Delphi/Scaling.lean). A theorem of a model carries no measurement; the records' own scope notes say nothing about the ostrich or the moa is established; the birds appear only in the claim's title. A formal statement cannot be fitted to held-out data and cannot be scored on it either, so it neither contaminates nor burns the exam.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"lean/laws.json","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): Lean 4 statements of Thompson's flight-scaling law and its corollary (lean/Delphi/Scaling.lean). A theorem of a model carries no measurement; the records' own scope notes say nothing about the ostrich or the moa is established; the birds appear only in the claim's title. A formal statement cannot be fitted to held-out data and cannot be scored on it either, so it neither contaminates nor burns the exam.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"lean/nanopubs/check.json","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): Lean 4 statements of Thompson's flight-scaling law and its corollary (lean/Delphi/Scaling.lean). A theorem of a model carries no measurement; the records' own scope notes say nothing about the ostrich or the moa is established; the birds appear only in the claim's title. A formal statement cannot be fitted to held-out data and cannot be scored on it either, so it neither contaminates nor burns the exam.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"nanopubs-index/calls.json","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"the curator's index of every unsigned draft in the tree quotes each record's head, including the holdout's own burned record (Columba livia) and the pre-freeze claim records; it is an index of records, not a builder","what_distinct":1},{"file":"physics/FORMAL-STATEMENTS.md","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): the physics thread tested Thompson's flight-scaling law, a claim whose inventory organisms are birds, on flying fish and other non-bird fliers with class Aves excluded (physics/tests/thompson1917-ch02-06/result.json, verdict inconclusive). The law is about any flier; the test used no bird row; the held-out birds remain available for a blind exam of the same law.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"physics/nanopubs/unsigned/evidence-muscle-power-cannot-tell.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): the physics thread tested Thompson's flight-scaling law, a claim whose inventory organisms are birds, on flying fish and other non-bird fliers with class Aves excluded (physics/tests/thompson1917-ch02-06/result.json, verdict inconclusive). The law is about any flier; the test used no bird row; the held-out birds remain available for a blind exam of the same law.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"physics/nanopubs/unsigned/finding-fishbase-length-weight-coverage.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): the physics thread tested Thompson's flight-scaling law, a claim whose inventory organisms are birds, on flying fish and other non-bird fliers with class Aves excluded (physics/tests/thompson1917-ch02-06/result.json, verdict inconclusive). The law is about any flier; the test used no bird row; the held-out birds remain available for a blind exam of the same law.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"physics/nanopubs/unsigned/finding-flying-fish-glide-data-coverage.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): the physics thread tested Thompson's flight-scaling law, a claim whose inventory organisms are birds, on flying fish and other non-bird fliers with class Aves excluded (physics/tests/thompson1917-ch02-06/result.json, verdict inconclusive). The law is about any flier; the test used no bird row; the held-out birds remain available for a blind exam of the same law.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"physics/nanopubs/unsigned/finding-wind-tunnel-specimens-proportioned-like-flying-fish.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): the physics thread tested Thompson's flight-scaling law, a claim whose inventory organisms are birds, on flying fish and other non-bird fliers with class Aves excluded (physics/tests/thompson1917-ch02-06/result.json, verdict inconclusive). The law is about any flier; the test used no bird row; the held-out birds remain available for a blind exam of the same law.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"physics/nanopubs/unsigned/finding-winged-zebrafish-cannot-launch.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): the physics thread tested Thompson's flight-scaling law, a claim whose inventory organisms are birds, on flying fish and other non-bird fliers with class Aves excluded (physics/tests/thompson1917-ch02-06/result.json, verdict inconclusive). The law is about any flier; the test used no bird row; the held-out birds remain available for a blind exam of the same law.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"physics/nanopubs/unsigned/hypothesis-tff-v2-codesign-map.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): the physics thread tested Thompson's flight-scaling law, a claim whose inventory organisms are birds, on flying fish and other non-bird fliers with class Aves excluded (physics/tests/thompson1917-ch02-06/result.json, verdict inconclusive). The law is about any flier; the test used no bird row; the held-out birds remain available for a blind exam of the same law.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"physics/nanopubs/unsigned/hypothesis-truly-flying-fish-design-requirements.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): the physics thread tested Thompson's flight-scaling law, a claim whose inventory organisms are birds, on flying fish and other non-bird fliers with class Aves excluded (physics/tests/thompson1917-ch02-06/result.json, verdict inconclusive). The law is about any flier; the test used no bird row; the held-out birds remain available for a blind exam of the same law.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"physics/prior-art/raw/pmc-span-efficiency-2026.txt","n":2,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Apus apus","Strigiformes"],"reason":"full texts and search responses fetched from PMC, Europe PMC and Crossref for bat, insect and flying-fish flight prior art; the articles carry bird comparison tables. The physics thread states in physics/SEARCHES.md that bird rows of the one compiled table were dropped at parse time and no bird value was read into any file, and this scan finds no held-out name in any physics file outside raw/. Fetched articles are literature the thread read, not data it fitted.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"physics/tests/thompson1917-ch02-06/result.json","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): the physics thread tested Thompson's flight-scaling law, a claim whose inventory organisms are birds, on flying fish and other non-bird fliers with class Aves excluded (physics/tests/thompson1917-ch02-06/result.json, verdict inconclusive). The law is about any flier; the test used no bird row; the held-out birds remain available for a blind exam of the same law.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"simulation-readiness/readiness.json","n":2,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Struthio camelus"],"reason":"an organism tally of the rows a parameter-database query returned (one of twenty rows for the Danio rerio query is labelled ostrich); the thread's README states no bird data was fetched or used, and the tally counts a search hit it did not read","what_distinct":1},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/centralized-2026-10-31T05-59-47/log.jsonl","n":2,"kinds":["taxon","claim"],"what":["Columba livia","claim darwin1859-ch01-10"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/centralized-2026-10-31T05-59-47/summary.json","n":2,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/centralized-2026-10-31T06-10-21-rep1/log.jsonl","n":2,"kinds":["taxon","claim"],"what":["Columba livia","claim darwin1859-ch01-10"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/centralized-2026-10-31T06-10-21-rep1/summary.json","n":2,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/decentralized-2026-10-31T06-02-31/summary.json","n":2,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/decentralized-2026-10-31T06-02-31/verify/darwin1859-ch01-10.a2.json","n":2,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Columba livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/decentralized-2026-10-31T06-13-25-rep1/summary.json","n":2,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/isolated-2026-10-31T05-57-46/log.jsonl","n":2,"kinds":["taxon","claim"],"what":["Columba livia","claim darwin1859-ch01-10"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/isolated-2026-10-31T05-57-46/summary.json","n":2,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/single-2026-10-31T06-05-08/log.jsonl","n":2,"kinds":["taxon","claim"],"what":["Columba livia","claim darwin1859-ch01-10"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/single-2026-10-31T06-05-08/summary.json","n":2,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"thompson-growth-form/assessment/inputs/batch-5.json","n":2,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Apteryx","Gallus gallus"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On Growth and Form, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; same reasoning as darwin-origin/. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"thompson-growth-form/extraction/H-ch12-15.json","n":2,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Apteryx","Gallus gallus"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On Growth and Form, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; same reasoning as darwin-origin/. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"thompson-growth-form/nanopubs/signed/thompson1917-ch02-06.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On Growth and Form, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; same reasoning as darwin-origin/. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"thompson-growth-form/nanopubs/unsigned/thompson1917-ch02-06.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On Growth and Form, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; same reasoning as darwin-origin/. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"truth/inputs/batch-01.json","n":2,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Columba livia"],"reason":"truth-scoring batches of the extracted claims, first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the bird claims are quoted, not built on.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"truth/inputs/batch-07.json","n":2,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Apteryx","Gallus gallus"],"reason":"truth-scoring batches of the extracted claims, first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; the bird claims are quoted, not built on.","what_distinct":2},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/lean/laws.json","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"published copy of the lean thread's data; same ruling as lean/","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/physics/data/FORMAL-STATEMENTS.md","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"published copy of the physics thread's data; same ruling as physics/","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/physics/data/nanopubs/evidence-muscle-power-cannot-tell.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"published copy of the physics thread's data; same ruling as physics/","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/physics/data/nanopubs/finding-fishbase-length-weight-coverage.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"published copy of the physics thread's data; same ruling as physics/","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/physics/data/nanopubs/finding-flying-fish-glide-data-coverage.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"published copy of the physics thread's data; same ruling as physics/","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/physics/data/nanopubs/finding-wind-tunnel-specimens-proportioned-like-flying-fish.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"published copy of the physics thread's data; same ruling as physics/","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/physics/data/nanopubs/finding-winged-zebrafish-cannot-launch.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"published copy of the physics thread's data; same ruling as physics/","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/physics/data/nanopubs/hypothesis-tff-v2-codesign-map.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"published copy of the physics thread's data; same ruling as physics/","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/physics/data/nanopubs/hypothesis-truly-flying-fish-design-requirements.trig","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"published copy of the physics thread's data; same ruling as physics/","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/physics/data/result.json","n":2,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"published copy of the physics thread's data; same ruling as physics/","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/runs/centralized/log.jsonl","n":2,"kinds":["taxon","claim"],"what":["Columba livia","claim darwin1859-ch01-10"],"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry","what_distinct":2},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/runs/centralized/summary.json","n":2,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry","what_distinct":2},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/runs/decentralized/summary.json","n":2,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry","what_distinct":2},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/runs/decentralized/verify/darwin1859-ch01-10.a2.json","n":2,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Columba livia"],"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/runs/isolated/log.jsonl","n":2,"kinds":["taxon","claim"],"what":["Columba livia","claim darwin1859-ch01-10"],"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry","what_distinct":2},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/runs/isolated/summary.json","n":2,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry","what_distinct":2},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/runs/single/log.jsonl","n":2,"kinds":["taxon","claim"],"what":["Columba livia","claim darwin1859-ch01-10"],"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry","what_distinct":2},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/runs/single/summary.json","n":2,"kinds":["claim","taxon"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10","Columba livia"],"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry","what_distinct":2},{"file":"claim-tests/thompson-growth-form/thompson1917-ch04-13/data/ccdb_statistics_Angiosperms.csv","n":1,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Troglodytes"],"reason":"homonym: Troglodytes here is an angiosperm genus in the Chromosome Counts Database, not the wren genus; the file holds plant chromosome counts only","what_distinct":1},{"file":"genotype/causal-chains.json","n":1,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Gallus gallus"],"reason":"the organism field of a cited experiment (Ng 2002: zebrafish and chick) on one gene-to-phenotype link for the fin genes; a literature citation naming the chick as one of two experimental organisms, no bird trait value. Disclosed to the genotype thread.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"lean/laws/build-laws.mjs","n":1,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): Lean 4 statements of Thompson's flight-scaling law and its corollary (lean/Delphi/Scaling.lean). A theorem of a model carries no measurement; the records' own scope notes say nothing about the ostrich or the moa is established; the birds appear only in the claim's title. A formal statement cannot be fitted to held-out data and cannot be scored on it either, so it neither contaminates nor burns the exam.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"lean/LAWS.md","n":1,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): Lean 4 statements of Thompson's flight-scaling law and its corollary (lean/Delphi/Scaling.lean). A theorem of a model carries no measurement; the records' own scope notes say nothing about the ostrich or the moa is established; the birds appear only in the claim's title. A formal statement cannot be fitted to held-out data and cannot be scored on it either, so it neither contaminates nor burns the exam.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"lean/nanopubs/unsigned/scope-thompson1917-ch02-06.trig","n":1,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): Lean 4 statements of Thompson's flight-scaling law and its corollary (lean/Delphi/Scaling.lean). A theorem of a model carries no measurement; the records' own scope notes say nothing about the ostrich or the moa is established; the birds appear only in the claim's title. A formal statement cannot be fitted to held-out data and cannot be scored on it either, so it neither contaminates nor burns the exam.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"lean/nanopubs/unsigned/scope-thompson1917-ch02-07.trig","n":1,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): Lean 4 statements of Thompson's flight-scaling law and its corollary (lean/Delphi/Scaling.lean). A theorem of a model carries no measurement; the records' own scope notes say nothing about the ostrich or the moa is established; the birds appear only in the claim's title. A formal statement cannot be fitted to held-out data and cannot be scored on it either, so it neither contaminates nor burns the exam.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"nanopubs-index/README.md","n":1,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10"],"reason":"the curator's index of every unsigned draft in the tree quotes each record's head, including the holdout's own burned record (Columba livia) and the pre-freeze claim records; it is an index of records, not a builder","what_distinct":1},{"file":"organism-design/nanopubs/UPSTREAM-ASK.md","n":1,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10"],"reason":"refers to the holdout's own burned record for that claim by file name","what_distinct":1},{"file":"physics/prior-art/raw/cr-fish-1990.json","n":1,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Columba livia"],"reason":"full texts and search responses fetched from PMC, Europe PMC and Crossref for bat, insect and flying-fish flight prior art; the articles carry bird comparison tables. The physics thread states in physics/SEARCHES.md that bird rows of the one compiled table were dropped at parse time and no bird value was read into any file, and this scan finds no held-out name in any physics file outside raw/. Fetched articles are literature the thread read, not data it fitted.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"physics/prior-art/raw/epmc-C-bat-muscle.json","n":1,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Anatidae"],"reason":"full texts and search responses fetched from PMC, Europe PMC and Crossref for bat, insect and flying-fish flight prior art; the articles carry bird comparison tables. The physics thread states in physics/SEARCHES.md that bird rows of the one compiled table were dropped at parse time and no bird value was read into any file, and this scan finds no held-out name in any physics file outside raw/. Fetched articles are literature the thread read, not data it fitted.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"physics/prior-art/raw/epmc-flight-scaling.json","n":1,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Apus apus"],"reason":"full texts and search responses fetched from PMC, Europe PMC and Crossref for bat, insect and flying-fish flight prior art; the articles carry bird comparison tables. The physics thread states in physics/SEARCHES.md that bird rows of the one compiled table were dropped at parse time and no bird value was read into any file, and this scan finds no held-out name in any physics file outside raw/. Fetched articles are literature the thread read, not data it fitted.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"physics/prior-art/raw/epmc-insect-speed.json","n":1,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Columba livia"],"reason":"full texts and search responses fetched from PMC, Europe PMC and Crossref for bat, insect and flying-fish flight prior art; the articles carry bird comparison tables. The physics thread states in physics/SEARCHES.md that bird rows of the one compiled table were dropped at parse time and no bird value was read into any file, and this scan finds no held-out name in any physics file outside raw/. Fetched articles are literature the thread read, not data it fitted.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"physics/prior-art/raw/pmc-fastest-bats-2016.txt","n":1,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Apus apus"],"reason":"full texts and search responses fetched from PMC, Europe PMC and Crossref for bat, insect and flying-fish flight prior art; the articles carry bird comparison tables. The physics thread states in physics/SEARCHES.md that bird rows of the one compiled table were dropped at parse time and no bird value was read into any file, and this scan finds no held-out name in any physics file outside raw/. Fetched articles are literature the thread read, not data it fitted.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"physics/prior-art/raw/pmc-mousetailed-bats-2026.txt","n":1,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Apus apus"],"reason":"full texts and search responses fetched from PMC, Europe PMC and Crossref for bat, insect and flying-fish flight prior art; the articles carry bird comparison tables. The physics thread states in physics/SEARCHES.md that bird rows of the one compiled table were dropped at parse time and no bird value was read into any file, and this scan finds no held-out name in any physics file outside raw/. Fetched articles are literature the thread read, not data it fitted.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"physics/PRIOR-ART.md","n":1,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): the physics thread tested Thompson's flight-scaling law, a claim whose inventory organisms are birds, on flying fish and other non-bird fliers with class Aves excluded (physics/tests/thompson1917-ch02-06/result.json, verdict inconclusive). The law is about any flier; the test used no bird row; the held-out birds remain available for a blind exam of the same law.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"physics/sources.json","n":1,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"Ruled not a leak by the holdout thread on 2026-10-31 (holdout/rulings.json, formal-statements-of-bird-linked-claims): the physics thread tested Thompson's flight-scaling law, a claim whose inventory organisms are birds, on flying fish and other non-bird fliers with class Aves excluded (physics/tests/thompson1917-ch02-06/result.json, verdict inconclusive). The law is about any flier; the test used no bird row; the held-out birds remain available for a blind exam of the same law.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"swarm/compare/claims2.json","n":1,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch07-04"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/centralized-2026-10-31T05-59-47/verify/darwin1859-ch01-10.a1.json","n":1,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Columba livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/centralized-2026-10-31T06-10-21-rep1/verify/darwin1859-ch01-10.a1.json","n":1,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Columba livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/decentralized-2026-10-31T06-13-25-rep1/verify/darwin1859-ch01-10.a1.json","n":1,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Columba livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/isolated-2026-10-31T05-57-46/verify/darwin1859-ch01-10.a1.json","n":1,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Columba livia"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/isolated-2026-10-31T06-08-36-rep1/verify/darwin1859-ch01-10.a1.json","n":1,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["NCBI taxid 8932"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/single-2026-10-31T05-57-45/log.jsonl","n":1,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"swarm/compare/runs/single-2026-10-31T05-57-45/summary.json","n":1,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10"],"reason":"swarm comparison inputs, plans, calls, summaries and DEVIATIONS.md for claim darwin1859-ch01-10, which is burned (holdout/burned.json) and disclosed in swarm/compare/DEVIATIONS.md; workers write plans and download no organism data. Any other held-out bird under swarm/compare/ is still a leak. The claim ids ch01-10 (burned) and ch07-04 (skipped, as the pre-registration says) are tolerated here for the same reason.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"swarm/PREREG.md","n":1,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch07-04"],"reason":"the swarm pre-registration names the bird claims it skipped (ch07-04) and the one it had already started (ch01-10, burned); naming an id is how it says so","what_distinct":1},{"file":"thompson-growth-form/assessment/inputs/batch-1.json","n":1,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On Growth and Form, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; same reasoning as darwin-origin/. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"thompson-growth-form/assessment/raw/gpt/batch-1.json","n":1,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On Growth and Form, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; same reasoning as darwin-origin/. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"thompson-growth-form/assessment/raw/grok/batch-1.json","n":1,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On Growth and Form, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; same reasoning as darwin-origin/. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"thompson-growth-form/assessment/raw/grok/batch-5.json","n":1,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Apteryx"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On Growth and Form, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; same reasoning as darwin-origin/. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"thompson-growth-form/extraction/notation.json","n":1,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On Growth and Form, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; same reasoning as darwin-origin/. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"thompson-growth-form/inputs/pg55264.txt","n":1,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Apteryx"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On Growth and Form, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; same reasoning as darwin-origin/. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"thompson-growth-form/nanopubs/assessments-signed/thompson1917-ch15-02--grok.trig","n":1,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Apteryx"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On Growth and Form, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; same reasoning as darwin-origin/. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"thompson-growth-form/nanopubs/assessments-unsigned/thompson1917-ch15-02--grok.trig","n":1,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Apteryx"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On Growth and Form, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; same reasoning as darwin-origin/. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"thompson-growth-form/nanopubs/signed/thompson1917-ch15-02.trig","n":1,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Apteryx"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On Growth and Form, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; same reasoning as darwin-origin/. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"thompson-growth-form/nanopubs/signed/thompson1917-ch15-03.trig","n":1,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Gallus gallus"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On Growth and Form, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; same reasoning as darwin-origin/. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"thompson-growth-form/nanopubs/unsigned/thompson1917-ch15-02.trig","n":1,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Apteryx"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On Growth and Form, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; same reasoning as darwin-origin/. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"thompson-growth-form/nanopubs/unsigned/thompson1917-ch15-03.trig","n":1,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Gallus gallus"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On Growth and Form, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; same reasoning as darwin-origin/. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"thompson-growth-form/worklist.tsv","n":1,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"claim extraction, assessments and claim nanopubs cut from On Growth and Form, all first committed on 2026-10-30, before the first freeze; same reasoning as darwin-origin/. A file first committed after the freeze is not tolerated by this entry.","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/genotype/data.json","n":1,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Gallus gallus"],"reason":"published copy of genotype/causal-chains.json; same reasoning","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/physics/data/PRIOR-ART.md","n":1,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"published copy of the physics thread's data; same ruling as physics/","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/physics/data/sources.json","n":1,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim thompson1917-ch02-06"],"reason":"published copy of the physics thread's data; same ruling as physics/","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/claims2.json","n":1,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch07-04"],"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/PREREG.md","n":1,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch07-04"],"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/runs/centralized/index.json","n":1,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10"],"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/runs/centralized/verify/darwin1859-ch01-10.a1.json","n":1,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Columba livia"],"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/runs/decentralized/index.json","n":1,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10"],"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/runs/isolated/index.json","n":1,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10"],"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/runs/isolated/verify/darwin1859-ch01-10.a1.json","n":1,"kinds":["taxon"],"what":["Columba livia"],"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry","what_distinct":1},{"file":"dashboard/public/t/swarm/runs/single/index.json","n":1,"kinds":["claim"],"what":["claim darwin1859-ch01-10"],"reason":"published copy of swarm/compare/ and the swarm pre-registration; same reasoning as the swarm/compare/ entry","what_distinct":1}],"allowlist_entries":26,"files_scanned":7276,"hit_lines":0},"power_finding":"POWER.md"}